bakesy said...red thumbs for a surf report on a surf report thread? Doggie please don't report on forecast swell on a swell forecast website or maybe it was the holiday thing that earned you the thumbing

What i reckon it is, is one man's good surf isn't good to another man. I reckon you deserve praise for putting up a surf report, just like you said! Some blokes are too fussy when it comes to waves quality and it turns out they only surf once in a blue moon! In the end, they end up negative, call everything ** and generally don't stay paddle fit. I even somewhat agree with the great Suba, just gotta get out.
So... no red thumbs from me me mate. If it was knee high and you could even perhaps ride a mal, just have a crack; cheers for the report. Stuff the fuss pots! It's not like I'm a great surfer anyway! Haha!