when shoud vent plugs be removed

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Ian K
Ian K
WA
4169 posts
WA, 4169 posts
7 Jan 2013 12:17pm
mahi said...
I have witnessed a mates board explode while driving up the volcano in Maui. Sounded like popcorn cooking as the sandwich skin was delaminating off the eps core. Some valve screws need to be removed completely ! Not just backed off.
The bottom of the board was as domed as the deck when we pulled it out of the board bag - haha


The Volcano in Maui is 3000 metres, so that's 2.5 times the pressure difference in CJW's worst case example. But cars get pretty hot, vans without many windows are much cooler.

Sensible British units may be easier to get your head around. 1.3 newtons per square centimetre is the same as 271 lbs hanging off each square foot. Not surprising that once a flaw develops in the glue line it keeps going.....No wind today, just going out to the van to get a few boards out and into the shade.
richoo
richoo
WA
5 posts
WA, 5 posts
7 Jan 2013 4:25pm
Always remove vent when not in water. I can't believe people think this is too much effort. We load up car/trailer head down beach, then rig up sail, get board out, put sunscreen on, put wetter on, lock car, walk equipment down beach. We do all this religiously but think its too much to put a screw in which takes 5 secs. Mmm
cammd
cammd
QLD
4437 posts
QLD, 4437 posts
7 Jan 2013 8:36pm
I think the argument for leaving the vent screwed in based on personal experience of never having had a problem would be similar to a smoker arguing that all health warnings are rubbish based on good personal health so far.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12872 posts
WA, 12872 posts
7 Jan 2013 6:47pm
sboardcrazy said...
My plugs have the one side that is flat but if the plugs have an O ring on how does the air escape the board when the plug is loose?


Don't worry too much it's highly unlikely the o ring will seal around the thread and walls of the insert, it would have to be a very soft and oversized o ring, with a smear of grease on the threads before this could happen.

actionmax said.....
I'm not sure what's right
But I do agree with barn that having no washer can pinch & twist o ring so it doesn't seal
& so why do vent plugs get made this way ? If it is so critical; the plugs would b designed not to chew up the o rings


Adding a washer, could stuff up the seal, it's metal to metal between washer and plug head.
Carantoc
Carantoc
WA
7268 posts
WA, 7268 posts
7 Jan 2013 7:27pm
From what I read here it seems that those in WA need to remove the plug and those in Qld don't.

Clearly this is a daylight savings issue. The extra hour of light must somehow warm the board up more.

Personally after I have removed, checked, cleaned, greased, kissed and polished the plug I then blow dry the footstraps with my 12v hairdryer.

appleman
appleman
TAS
443 posts
TAS, 443 posts
8 Jan 2013 1:05am
Carantoc said...
From what I read here it seems that those in WA need to remove the plug and those in Qld don't.

Clearly this is a daylight savings issue. The extra hour of light must somehow warm the board up more.

Personally after I have removed, checked, cleaned, greased, kissed and polished the plug I then blow dry the footstraps with my 12v hairdryer.


we also have daylight saving down south. .. ,but I don't think that has much to do with boards blowing up in TAS ,its the H 2 o in the board , cause ya metal washer gave , turning in to ice, expanding,and bang ya boards flappin ,or was it all just hot air? Durex for me

sboardcrazy
sboardcrazy
NSW
8333 posts
NSW, 8333 posts
11 Jan 2013 12:52pm
Ok say your board has now delaminated ( theoretical question -mine are great)..is it fixable and if so how?
I know it would depend on how bad but does anyone have any photos of a board that has died due to the plug being left tight so we can see what it looks like?
dinsdale
dinsdale
WA
1227 posts
WA, 1227 posts
11 Jan 2013 2:40pm
Carantoc said...
From what I read here it seems that those in WA need to remove the plug and those in Qld don't.

Clearly this is a daylight savings issue. The extra hour of light must somehow warm the board up more.

Hmmmm. How is this so? Neither QLD nor WA has daylight saving, so one would expect their experiences to be the same. Methinks there's something weird at play here .


nasty
nasty
WA
153 posts
WA, 153 posts
11 Jan 2013 3:49pm
I always unscrew the plug and then wedge it (softly - don't damage the rubber) in the mast track. That way I can't screw a UJ in until I've remembered to put the plug back in.

It's idiot proof as evidenced by the fact that it works for me.
ka43
ka43
NSW
3101 posts
NSW, 3101 posts
11 Jan 2013 10:38pm
A good example.
Ive been doing a small ding repair on a mates board. Nothing big, just deep enough to get to the styrofoam.
Being an "undoer" I did all the right things (rinsed, dried and sanded) and when ready slapped on the epoxy. straight away small air bubbles started popping out of the ding.
Bugger, straight away turned the board over and undid the valve.
Never been undone before (board approx 4 seasons old) , hiss of air and bubbles stopped.
resin had started to harden by this stage so began again. Ding repair worked sweet.
You be the judge, probably why the makers put the warnings on your board
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12872 posts
WA, 12872 posts
11 Jan 2013 10:09pm
sboardcrazy said...
Ok say your board has now delaminated ( theoretical question -mine are great)..is it fixable and if so how?
I know it would depend on how bad but does anyone have any photos of a board that has died due to the plug being left tight so we can see what it looks like?


There's basically 3 methods,
1, drill holes in the board and inject resin, then weight or vacuum bag the bottom down.
I haven't tried this one, but others have reported success.

2, cut around edges of delam with short bladed jig saw, (about 5mm long), remove, brush on glue then same as before with bottom. sand around cuts and glass/carbon over. This will work if the core foam isn't too damaged.
3, if the core foam is badly damaged, ie bits of loose compressed foam floating around, the core has to be smoothed off, (I use a router in a travelling jig on rails). New core material glued in to level of underside of sandwich. After this I've tried cheating and used the original bottom, but it didn't really work, it's better to apply a completely new sandwich.

This last is a time consuming process, probably better to buy a second hand board, if you aren't doing it yourself.
sboardcrazy
sboardcrazy
NSW
8333 posts
NSW, 8333 posts
12 Jan 2013 10:14am
decrepit said...
sboardcrazy said...
Ok say your board has now delaminated ( theoretical question -mine are great)..is it fixable and if so how?
I know it would depend on how bad but does anyone have any photos of a board that has died due to the plug being left tight so we can see what it looks like?


There's basically 3 methods,
1, drill holes in the board and inject resin, then weight or vacuum bag the bottom down.
I haven't tried this one, but others have reported success.

2, cut around edges of delam with short bladed jig saw, (about 5mm long), remove, brush on glue then same as before with bottom. sand around cuts and glass/carbon over. This will work if the core foam isn't too damaged.
3, if the core foam is badly damaged, ie bits of loose compressed foam floating around, the core has to be smoothed off, (I use a router in a travelling jig on rails). New core material glued in to level of underside of sandwich. After this I've tried cheating and used the original bottom, but it didn't really work, it's better to apply a completely new sandwich.

This last is a time consuming process, probably better to buy a second hand board, if you aren't doing it yourself.


Sounds like it would be worth getting a repairer to quote before you ditch a board and buy another...?
deejay8204
deejay8204
QLD
557 posts
QLD, 557 posts
12 Jan 2013 9:46am
cammd said...
I think the argument for leaving the vent screwed in based on personal experience of never having had a problem would be similar to a smoker arguing that all health warnings are rubbish based on good personal health so far.


Agreed. I always think of the "What If" something happens, Lots of $$$ to fix or lots of $$$ to buy new stuff later. Neither of my boards have vents but if they did, not hard to undo and do up I would think.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12872 posts
WA, 12872 posts
12 Jan 2013 7:41pm
deejay8204 said...
Neither of my boards have vents but if they did, not hard to undo and do up I would think.


Don't underestimate this it's a right pain in the ar$3!!!!
Agreed the actual physical work involved is minimal, but some of us area little absent minded, remembering to do it is one of the problems!

Then there's getting sand or grit under the o ring and it not sealing.

Having one from the factory that doesn't seal properly and you don't notice it.

Loosening at the beach only to have it fall out somewhere between there and your next intended session.

Somebody else does it up for you and over tightens it, tearing the o ring.

There's probably more to this list, and there's ways to cope with them.
But you've got the best answer, NO bung at all!!!!!!
Bluedog76
Bluedog76
249 posts
249 posts
12 Jan 2013 8:22pm
For the last year and a half I have stored my board undercover in it's bag with the vent screw almost out (a few turns left) when not in the water. The storage area is in a rack (standing upright) with other boards around it and open on all sides.

I brought the board home today and noticed a large bubble/delaminated area (about a quarter of the bottom surface area) on my 2 year old isonic 121....it's been used under ten times. It is in Singapore where everyday is 28-32 degrees with high humidity and showers/t-storms thus rain has probably wet the bag (lightly) at times.

Should I have removed the plug completely or not at all or is the delam due to something else?
R1DER
R1DER
WA
1474 posts
WA, 1474 posts
12 Jan 2013 11:57pm
Bluedog76 said...
For the last year and a half I have stored my board undercover in it's bag with the vent screw almost out (a few turns left) when not in the water. The storage area is in a rack (standing upright) with other boards around it and open on all sides.

I brought the board home today and noticed a large bubble/delaminated area (about a quarter of the bottom surface area) on my 2 year old isonic 121....it's been used under ten times. It is in Singapore where everyday is 28-32 degrees with high humidity and showers/t-storms thus rain has probably wet the bag (lightly) at times.

Should I have removed the plug completely or not at all or is the delam due to something else?


delam due to something else, probably manufacturing defect.
Milsy
Milsy
NSW
1176 posts
NSW, 1176 posts
13 Jan 2013 7:48am
YAWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12872 posts
WA, 12872 posts
13 Jan 2013 8:08pm
Bluedog76 said...
For the last year and a half I have stored my board undercover in it's bag with the vent screw almost out (a few turns left) when not in the water. The storage area is in a rack (standing upright) with other boards around it and open on all sides.

I brought the board home today and noticed a large bubble/delaminated area (about a quarter of the bottom surface area) on my 2 year old isonic 121....it's been used under ten times. It is in Singapore where everyday is 28-32 degrees with high humidity and showers/t-storms thus rain has probably wet the bag (lightly) at times.

Should I have removed the plug completely or not at all or is the delam due to something else?


Check that it's not just the paint that's bubbling, sounds like there's no reason for the sandwich to give way, but hot humid conditions, in a board bag can affect paint.
Bluedog76
Bluedog76
249 posts
249 posts
13 Jan 2013 8:48pm
I can definitely push the skin down to meet the foam thus think it is more than just the paint.
jn1
jn1
SA
2753 posts
jn1 jn1
SA, 2753 posts
12 Feb 2013 12:18am
An idea I'm going to try tonight. This is taken from the aircraft world. A "Remove Before Sail" indicator.

In winter, I normally leave them in (very little temperature change). Summer time, I vent my boards when not in use. I normally do up the screws at home when I'm packing, but tomorrow I'm going for a sail after work and taking my gear to work. It's going to be +30C at my work, and even hotter in the car. I don't want to have my board in the car with the vent screw done up and I'm one of those people who forget little details like doing up the vent screw; doubly so in the rigging area when saying hello to people and all the other distractions.



It's a off cut from a foam mat (you get at Clark Rubber or Bunnings). It's the same width as a mast track. This is the rules: When it's in, the vent screw is open. It's impossible to fit a base. Before flight (sail), do up vent screw, then remove indicator. After sail, slide indicator back in rail, undo vent screw.

Hope that helps

J
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
11 Feb 2013 10:33pm
still have to remember to put the thingy in the track after sailing
GazMan
GazMan
WA
848 posts
WA, 848 posts
12 Feb 2013 12:53am
Have been thinking of another option lately. What about a sort of 'vent plug holder' consisting of a threaded hole or fitting in the mast track that one could thread the vent plug into once its removed? It would be difficult to forget putting the vent plug in if its in your way when you try to fit the mast base into the track!

Milsy
Milsy
NSW
1176 posts
NSW, 1176 posts
12 Feb 2013 9:43am
for the forgetful,, wht not a message on board bag, DONT FORGET PLUG, personally i dont mess with plug much, but when its hot, over about 35, i bring boards out of shed and put them in the cooler house.......then i put wife in shed, its sweet, a win/win
sboardcrazy
sboardcrazy
NSW
8333 posts
NSW, 8333 posts
12 Feb 2013 12:32pm
Milsy said...
for the forgetful,, wht not a message on board bag, DONT FORGET PLUG, personally i dont mess with plug much, but when its hot, over about 35, i bring boards out of shed and put them in the cooler house.......then i put wife in shed, its sweet, a win/win


Boy your wife's tolerant..
Cambodge
Cambodge
VIC
851 posts
VIC, 851 posts
12 Feb 2013 12:33pm
Milsy, I bet the wife's hissing and bubbling when you take her out of the shed!
jn1
jn1
SA
2753 posts
jn1 jn1
SA, 2753 posts
12 Feb 2013 10:04pm
Mark: No system is completely idiot proof - "ya can't fix stupid" :)
Paul Kelf
Paul Kelf
WA
678 posts
WA, 678 posts
13 Feb 2013 11:15am
jn1 said...





Some brads of board have the vent screw at the other end of the mast track which works well.
You cannot fit the base without tightening the vent screw.
Unfortunately you could till forget to un-screw the vent after removing the base.
seanhogan
seanhogan
QLD
3424 posts
QLD, 3424 posts
13 Feb 2013 4:17pm
still a better option !!!

don't know of other brands apart from Exocet that have that system ?
Beaglebuddy
Beaglebuddy
1595 posts
1595 posts
13 Feb 2013 5:16pm
If you must remove the plug, put it into the two bolt base bit that stays attached to the board, it stays captive in there and you cannot attach the rig to the board without dealing with it.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅