Gestalt said...
not meant to be insulting.
you can't possibly expect to go from running race sails and being completely loaded up to getting the most out of a small sail in the same wind. i know this because that's what i did myself.
it does take time. it's not just about bearing away.
don't get me wrong, i'm not saying you shouldn't be running bigger sails. not at all.
what i am saying is.
people who say a heavy weight on a 6.5m sail in 15-20 knots cant be planning around sailing upwind and down with ease are wrong. a really good sailor would have a 5.8 planning in those winds
'A really good sailor'? What is that? One who is trying to prove how small a sail they can use? One who can go faster than another? One who can comfortably plane out of gybes? There are so many variables, and would a really good sailor want to sail a rig where they had to put in a lot of effort and not be that comfortable?
I think this is where the understanding of the actual windspeed comes into it too. A real 20 knots, yes, a 6.5m not a problem. Trouble is that a lot of people assume it is 20 knots when its only 16, so their comparison is meaningless.
Similarly, I think someone saying they use a 8.5m in 25+ knots is probably not right. Sure, you can do it, but it probably won't be comfortable. I keep on having a problem with Macro saying he was sailing 6m+ sails in 30 knots. I just don't believe it for someone his weight.
I do love the range you can get with race sails though. Lots of flexibility, and comfortable.Comparing sailors like this is not easy. Different boards, different sails, and different fins.
There was one day in Safety Bay this season, where the wind finally came in, and there were only three of us out there. I was on a 8.5m and a 125L iSonic. The other guys were on smaller boards and smaller sails. Glenn was on a 5.7m sail and still planing fast. He was sailing well on a sail almost 3 metres smaller than mine and I couldn't argue I was heavier either.
He sure had to do a lot of pumping to get started though. He seemed to have a nice floaty board and a decent fin, so it probably made a bit of a difference too.
The point of this? It is very difficult to compare sailors. Me, I would prefer to have enough sails and boards to be able to sail comfortably in whatever wind speed is out there.