Piros said..
Nice call Hilly but I don't call it a Fad yet still room for improvements. I think you'll see the noses round up more and the tails square off like the Thomo design. These boards have their days where they just rip but in some fatter sloppy conditions they do struggle. If you can afford more than one board it's a must in your quiver but if you are a one board Supper this isn't your board.
We now have 4 major brands put out production models: Sunova 1st , then Gulliver , JP and even Naish. Sunova designs are pretty radical , JP & Gulliver is more the proven design so far and Naish have gone super short and fat. Deep has lead the way with customs and by far sold the most plus we have a bunch of other custom shapers and home made jobs. Everyone has their own theories on how to blow up this original Vanguard shortboard shape.
Personally I love it always keen on new stuff. One really interesting fact none of the top team riders are competing on them that has to say something.
Piros in terms of the fact that as you say none of the top team riders are competing on them there are a number of reasonable factors to consider.
At the end of the day this is a commercial business and the major players offer a wide variety of boards which go from the extremely short to the overly long with a whole
range of board sizes in between. Just taking the Minion as an example, we see here that you have a product which can cater for guys who are ultra light, say under 70kg as well
as the big boys who are 115kg and yet keep the board well under 8 feet. It just comes down to how artfully you distribute the volume on these parallel boards. I would suggest then
that it would be commercially disadvantageous to the bigger players by narrowing the size down. How do they sell the boards which are 8'6, 9'0, 9'6, 10 etc which guys are using for
surfing purposes? Okay yes there will always be a market for the flatwater range regardless of how small the boards become but that is a speciality area. What do they do with all these
templates? They are basically shooting themselves in the foot by doing this. Now compare that again to the minion. It really took one thread from Casso and the exposure that it received
was such that we saw an explosion in interest for these boards which also translated in huge sales as well as an overwhelming positive response. Now if I had a choice of taking
Kai Lennys advice on board recommendation I need to balance that with his personal interests given that he is sponsored by Naish - he has a financial commitment there. On the other
hand I would be more inclined to look at the plethora of positive responses from guys that have bought a minion who have NO financial interest whatsoever. I would view their remarks
with a greater level of objectivity than Kai Lenny's.
These boards work, there is no doubt about that. If they didnt we would have an entire thread from disgruntled SUPers and no amount of affirmations from Kai Lenny could dispel negative feedback from the public.