kitesurfing verses windsurfing?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
davidf
davidf
NSW
21 posts
NSW, 21 posts
11 Jul 2007 8:57pm
We all know you take bigger airs kitesurfing.

Why is wind surfing better.

Why should i try windsurfing when I already do kitesurfing.
fitz66
fitz66
QLD
575 posts
QLD, 575 posts
11 Jul 2007 9:24pm
Who said windsurfing is better
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
11 Jul 2007 7:28pm
First post a troll?

Nice going Davo, stay off the Boags.
fitz66
fitz66
QLD
575 posts
QLD, 575 posts
11 Jul 2007 9:31pm
windsurfers don't get to wear there pants outside their wetsuits
hoop
hoop
1979 posts
1979 posts
11 Jul 2007 7:33pm
Give him a break, he's obviously spent his teenage years being rellentlessly buggered by his uncles and father. Probably doesent know any different.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12872 posts
WA, 12872 posts
11 Jul 2007 7:36pm
Just in case you're not trolling, I'll try a sensible answer.

quote:
Originally posted by davidf



Why should i try windsurfing when I already do kitesurfing.



Strange question, do you want to windsurf as well??
If so why not just do it?
Very hard if not impossible for anybody else to answer that question for you.
There's so many aspects to windsurfing, ie, wave, freeride, speed, lots of forms of racing.
How do we know what turns you on?
Kiting has equivalents to some, but not sure how to compare them, you need somebody who is very proficient in all disciplines to compare them, and that is still only their experience.
The only way to find out, is to try it yourself.
But people I know who have done both say that windsurfing is a longer learning curve.
davidf
davidf
NSW
21 posts
NSW, 21 posts
11 Jul 2007 9:48pm
I am interested in windsurfing because i live on the derwent river and there isn't realy any where sutibal to lanch my kite. Do you think it would be a bad idea to buy a small wave board to start off on its just a big bourd would be a jobe to carry down.
fullmoon
fullmoon
WA
314 posts
WA, 314 posts
11 Jul 2007 7:54pm
Whats a troll?
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12872 posts
WA, 12872 posts
11 Jul 2007 8:00pm
A small wave board is very hard to learn on, not impossible if you've got steady 15knt - 20knt winds. Cause you have to learn to waterstart first, (if you're young, fit and keen, this is the fastest way anyhow). It is easier with a board that's at least 20 litres more than your kg weight, (has a bit more stability, and doesn't sink as much when you try to get up).

I wouldn't recommend teaching yourself, there's so many things you can do wrong, and end up just getting totally frustrated.
Having somebody there with you, who knows what they are doing and giving advice, is almost a must.
davidf
davidf
NSW
21 posts
NSW, 21 posts
11 Jul 2007 10:18pm
What sort of size sale would best soot a 75 liter board for 12 20 nots I weigh 55 kilo
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12872 posts
WA, 12872 posts
11 Jul 2007 8:20pm
Another thing, why a wave board??? Don't know the Derwent, but does it have waves? If you're not planning to get into waves, a fast freeride would probably be better.

And when you say "small waveboard", by that I think my body weight in litres or less, but other people may think differently, depending on their local conditions. It's all relative.
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12872 posts
WA, 12872 posts
11 Jul 2007 8:22pm
quote:
Originally posted by fullmoon

Whats a troll?


An attempt, to incite, inflame, stir and get an emotional response.
divaldo
divaldo
SA
2878 posts
SA, 2878 posts
11 Jul 2007 10:05pm
Something smells fishy
elmo
elmo
WA
8890 posts
WA, 8890 posts
11 Jul 2007 8:38pm
Being a Tazzie boy look up Mr Curac and have a chat with him, he can give you the low down
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12872 posts
WA, 12872 posts
11 Jul 2007 8:38pm
quote:
Originally posted by davidf

What sort of size sale would best soot a 75 liter board for 12 20 nots I weigh 55 kilo



Hmm, off the top of my head I'd say 4.5, but it's only a guess, any light weights out there with advice????

I'm close to 70kg and for that range I use a 5.3, but I don't get planing until 15kn. 12 - 15 is for subplaning wave riding.

Just done some calculations, a 4.5 for you is equivalent to a 5.7 for me, on a bigger board I can just get planing with a slalom sail about that wind strength, and I can hang onto it to about 25kn.

A 4.7 for you is equivalent to a 6 for me, if it's a good stable sail that would give your wind range.
davidf
davidf
NSW
21 posts
NSW, 21 posts
11 Jul 2007 11:05pm
thanx for the imfomation it sound as through a fast freeride may be better othough i am a keen surfer and i would like get out there in the waves. A freeride board i asumed was ushaly larger in aqivalant to a wave board and there for hader to take down
Sailhack
Sailhack
VIC
5000 posts
VIC, 5000 posts
11 Jul 2007 11:14pm
Perhaps not a troll, let's break the questions down...


quote:
Originally posted by davidf

We all know you take bigger airs kitesurfing.


I have seen the 'Tophat' Youtube vid, and I must admit, I've never seen a windsurfer 'hover' above trees either???

quote:
Why is wind surfing better..


Legitimate question? For me, I enjoy it, and want to progress (as have some friends of mine) into sailing in my latter years, ie; learning how to read the wind, etc. But for now, just enjoying the flat-water & chop (mid 30s beginner with footballer's knees, no big jumps for me!)

quote:
Why should i try windsurfing when I already do kitesurfing.



You don't have to, if you don't want to, but why not give another - outside, on-the-water, fun, fast, and extreme, sport a go??? I'd like to give kitesurfing a go one day, but there's only one guy here that does it (and he's a big bloke with a badge!!!)

Judging by the weight (55kgs), and the spelling/punctuation, this guy could either be -
(A) an uneducated troll.

(B) a 'kiter' who's just trying to stir the pot.

or (and I hope it's C)

(C) a legitimate kid wanting some advice.

Perhaps we should follow Decrepit's lead.....and "be nice, guys."
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12872 posts
WA, 12872 posts
11 Jul 2007 9:20pm
quote:
Originally posted by davidf

thanx for the imfomation it sound as through a fast freeride may be better othough i am a keen surfer and i would like get out there in the waves. A freeride board i asumed was ushaly larger in aqivalant to a wave board and there for hader to take down



I'm not an expert on freerides, but a 75l board, is a 75l board. There's a chance the freeride could be lighter, as it wouldn't need as much reinforcing for high flat landings. (don't quote me on that, as I said, don't know a lot about freeride).
But if you plan on getting into waves, go waveboard.
Sailhack
Sailhack
VIC
5000 posts
VIC, 5000 posts
11 Jul 2007 11:23pm
quote:
Originally posted by davidf

thanx for the imfomation it sound as through a fast freeride may be better othough i am a keen surfer and i would like get out there in the waves. A freeride board i asumed was ushaly larger in aqivalant to a wave board and there for hader to take down



There's some good 'cross' boards out there, freeride/freetyle/waves/speed. I can't give much advice on board size as I'm double your weight, although at 55kgs, I'd be looking at the smallest of the freeride-cross boards, the difference in weight to a wave of slightly less volume board might only be a kilo at the most, if you go for a 70lt or less, you'll possibly eventually 'get-it', but will probably take longer (if you don't give-up beforehand.)
decrepit
decrepit
WA
12872 posts
WA, 12872 posts
11 Jul 2007 9:27pm
quote:
Originally posted by Sailhack

Perhaps not a troll, let's break the questions down...
-----
-----
Perhaps we should follow Decrepit's lead.....and "be nice, guys."



Sometimes you just have to take the chance, that you're not wasting your time.
It only takes one of us per posting at the start, then it should become obvious which side the bread's buttered.
davidf hasn't responded to any of the doubting answers, that must show something.
hoop
hoop
1979 posts
1979 posts
12 Jul 2007 7:55am
He'd be better off using his time learning how to write properly. More people could understand his crap stirring then.
Steptoes Son
Steptoes Son
QLD
88 posts
QLD, 88 posts
12 Jul 2007 1:03pm
Mate, I'd be getting a biggest volume board I could find. I've been in the Derwent, in summer, it's freeeeeeeezing.
555
555
892 posts
555 555
892 posts
12 Jul 2007 11:08am
Windsurfing isn't better than kitesurfing any more than a saw is better than a chisel. They're different.

Windsurfing gear takes up a bit more space, and you probably need more of it than kiting gear, but then you can windsurf in tighter places and higher winds, and can safely setup, use, and pack up your gear by yourself from the first day. There's also much less risk of getting hung from a tree, another kiter, or the mast of a moored yacht if you're not kiting.

A lot of the good guys here kite when the wind is light, and windsurf when it cranks up and gets too scary for kiting. I've also met a guy who still kites in 30+ knots when the waves are over twice mast high..(no idea what kiting jargon is for that!)

There's something to be said for being able to let go of everything when you get it wrong and have it stop in the water not too far away.

If you're keen to try windsurfing as an option, see if you can find someone local to talk to - windsurfers are usually a pretty friendly bunch. Getting some rental gear for an afternoon is a good option too. You might discover that you hate not wearing your boardies on the outside!

Just make sure that the gear you try is suitable and set up properly, otherwise it can be nearly impossible to enjoy the experience.
555
555
892 posts
555 555
892 posts
12 Jul 2007 11:12am
You won't see a windsurfer doing this!

www.seabreeze.com.au/gallery/gallery.asp?imageid=5146
NR
NR
WA
517 posts
NR NR
WA, 517 posts
12 Jul 2007 12:42pm
Double mast high sounds way better than third of line high
jonnywinner
jonnywinner
NSW
19 posts
NSW, 19 posts
12 Jul 2007 3:44pm
but you will see this

www.seabreeze.com.au/gallery/gallery.asp?imageid=5145
The Grinch
The Grinch
WA
733 posts
WA, 733 posts
12 Jul 2007 2:40pm
quote:
Originally posted by jonnywinner

but you will see this

www.seabreeze.com.au/gallery/gallery.asp?imageid=5145



Yep. It takes the thrust of a Jet engine to get any speed out of an Ezzy!!!
mineral1
mineral1
WA
4564 posts
WA, 4564 posts
12 Jul 2007 4:36pm
quote:
Originally posted by The Grinch

quote:
Originally posted by jonnywinner

but you will see this

www.seabreeze.com.au/gallery/gallery.asp?imageid=5145



Yep. It takes the thrust of a Jet engine to get any speed out of an Ezzy!!!


Beaudifullll
LMAO
Greenroom
Greenroom
WA
7608 posts
WA, 7608 posts
12 Jul 2007 9:04pm
quote:
Originally posted by The Grinch

quote:
Originally posted by jonnywinner

but you will see this

www.seabreeze.com.au/gallery/gallery.asp?imageid=5145



Yep. It takes the thrust of a Jet engine to get any speed out of an Ezzy!!!


Sad but true
Sailhack
Sailhack
VIC
5000 posts
VIC, 5000 posts
12 Jul 2007 11:06pm
Where'd you go, Dave
davidf
davidf
NSW
21 posts
NSW, 21 posts
13 Jul 2007 6:45pm
My unclel has two sails and a boom mast that is in his shed in resnobal condition but about 15 years old. I'm not shore what the mast is made out of because i haven't had a good look but it is heavy do you think it would be a waist of time to get a newish board probably around 75 liter and use this rig?
I am thinking it will not peform well at all, and not realy be sutibal for water starting?
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅