a board (and a sail which is too big) let's roll

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
dougr
dougr
NSW
34 posts
NSW, 34 posts
28 Aug 2011 12:51am
I have just bought a slalom board (156l) second hand. It came with a massive 10m sail.

So I'm going to try and trade down to a 5/6 lt sail and then hit this season (my first)

- based in Sydney
- want to hit narrabean and botany bay
- want to know what type of wind I should go out in
- how should I check the weather? What time the night before?
- how does the wind usually pick up during the morning? (how early should I go/leave as I start out)
- mobydisc took me out in Jan this year but who else goes out in these areas that I can head out with?

Thanks so much in advance
Doug
shear tip
shear tip
NSW
1125 posts
NSW, 1125 posts
28 Aug 2011 8:59am
Don't get rid of that 10m sail, this is Sydney.

We'll need to know your ability / weight to work out what wind a 5.6 will suit you and your gear.

How wide is the board? What size fin did it come with? Big slalom boards are designed for huge sails and light wind. A 5.6m might not work that well with it. There are others here better suited to answer these questions...
jsnfok
jsnfok
WA
899 posts
WA, 899 posts
28 Aug 2011 2:29pm
the board will feel quite un balanced with a small sail, below 8.5 that is
confused
confused
NSW
175 posts
NSW, 175 posts
28 Aug 2011 8:12pm


If you are a beginner then a slalom board is going to be a bit entertaining. I'm wondering whether you bought the formula gear from the guy in Carlingford?

Let us know what you got and we can try and point you in the right direction for a good sail / rig to get going with. Also let us know ow much you weight and how much wsurfing you've done.

Narrabean a good place to start as its flat even in wind and the worst that can happen is a long walk home.

Will be easier to say re wind when you give us more detail on the kit and youe experience so far but anything up to about 18knts should be fine and initially 10+ or even slightly lighter will be good to go out in. You wont plane in the really light stuff but great to practice in.

Wind is all over the place in Sydney so just keep an eye on the forecast on here and as soon as its yellow its good for you atm.

When there is wind there are usually people around at the lake so have a chat and I'm sure they will help you out.

Important to get the right kit first off.
seano
seano
NSW
150 posts
NSW, 150 posts
28 Aug 2011 11:08pm
careful sailing in narrabeen if you have a 70cm fin...it will find a lot of sand banks!
dougr
dougr
NSW
34 posts
NSW, 34 posts
29 Aug 2011 2:53pm
Hi there,

Yes, bought the gear from David in Carlingford.

Have been windsurfing twice this year only - did a Christmas holidays as a teenager but other than that minimal.

I weigh 88kg.

The sail/mast combo is a 10.7m RS3 Neil Pryde.

I wanted a smaller sail to be easier to uphall until i get better balance/skill.

Please take this opportunity to tell me i've bought a lemon/what i need to do if this is the case please as i'm definitely a n00b.

Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
29 Aug 2011 3:49pm
Hi Doug,

good to see you are back into it.

I think that sail is way too big for you right now. Don't sell it as it could come in handy in the future but look at getting something around 6m in size to start with.

From the sound of it you bought a formula board which is quite wide and short. It will be a bit of a challenge to get used to. If you keep going with it you will be right.

The wind is generally more consistent and stronger over summer at Botany Bay. However when you are starting out Narrabeen Lake is fine. At either location there are usually plenty of people out windsurfing when the wind is up or predicted to be up.

I think most people base their decisions to go sailing from looking at the Seabreeze graphs. The forecasts are never 100% accurate, especially as they get into more long term forecasts. However the live readings are invaluable in establishing whether its worthwhile to drive down to the water. If I'm going to Narrabeen Lake I usually look at the North Head graph and subtract a few knots off the reading.

dougr
dougr
NSW
34 posts
NSW, 34 posts
29 Aug 2011 7:02pm
If i get a 5.7/6.7m sail, does it matter if second hand- what type of mast should i get?

anything i should be aware of when purchasing? (does anyone have one for sale that sounds like what i want? - will check for sale section, but would love some advice/recommendations)
jh2703
jh2703
NSW
1225 posts
NSW, 1225 posts
29 Aug 2011 8:06pm
I've got a 4.7 you can have if your ever down Gerroa way to pick it up, it's a bit small but will be ok for the real windy days...problem is you will have to buy a 400 mast to suit.

If your real new see if you can borrow a beginners board for a while then buy yourself a 140-160 freeride board until you get the hang of it. The freeride will be much better for you then a slalom or formula board, But keep it as it will come in handy sometime down the track.

But again if that's what you've got, it's all about time on the water and it all counts...10m sail scares me a bit though, Don't they put them on yachts?

Cheers.
dougr
dougr
NSW
34 posts
DunkO
DunkO
NSW
1150 posts
NSW, 1150 posts
29 Aug 2011 10:20pm
if its a formula board you may be able to float around on it but you'll struggle to progress. this is a performance board that is meant to plane. you'll never get into the foot straps (way too far out) and harness.

and yes the sail is too big.

you need to look at 5-6m ish and probable a wave sail as they are stronger with x-ply reinforcement through it. stop you from putting a knee though it when you fall of. this will mean new mast and boom. mast will need to match the sail. different masts have different curve to match various sail brands. i recomend a rdm (reduced diameter mast) as they are stronger. plenty of stuff for sale.

don't worry i too bought stuff that was no quite right when starting out. wish someone had steared me in the right direction.

possibly have a go on your formula board but you may want to look at a big learning board or really cheap old school board. you will out grow it quickly.

good luck ,stick with it.



confused
confused
NSW
175 posts
NSW, 175 posts
29 Aug 2011 10:43pm


That sail probably isn't quite right as it has cams but do chuck options up here and people will give you a good idea of whether its right or not.

He's asking a hell of a lot for it but this sort of sail would be a great options:
www.seabreeze.com.au/Classifieds/Windsurfing/Sails/~b21ip/2009-Neil-Pryde-Excess-64-metre.aspx?search=b6%2fLEVHqrBP6hrOBOI75HFmYAqHw2CVN9LhY7dL4N2s%3d

If you can know the price down a bit this might also be a good choice:
www.seabreeze.com.au/Classifieds/Windsurfing/Sails/~b12xk/2007-Gaastra-Remedy-64-metre.aspx?search=b6%2fLEVHqrBP6hrOBOI75HFmYAqHw2CVN9LhY7dL4N2s%3d

There are plenty around, just a case of finding the right one. Different sails need different masts and booms so I'd suggest finding a sail that works and then seeing if there is a good boom and mast to suit. I've got a 5.3 that you could have cheapish but I think that might be a bit small for you in Sydney winds.

OK, others have held off saying it but I would probably look to sell on the gear you bought, its going to really slow the learning curve. Sorry, I know you don't want to hear that. Did you tell the guy you bought it from that you were a beginner? If so it was a bit harsh of him to sell it to you. (sorry if I've just offended someone on this forum).

Starting off can be a bit of a minefield gearwise but it will be well worth it!!!!
DunkO
DunkO
NSW
1150 posts
NSW, 1150 posts
29 Aug 2011 10:54pm
confused said...



That sail probably isn't quite right as it has cams but do chuck options up here and people will give you a good idea of whether its right or not.

He's asking a hell of a lot for it but this sort of sail would be a great options:
www.seabreeze.com.au/Classifieds/Windsurfing/Sails/~b21ip/2009-Neil-Pryde-Excess-64-metre.aspx?search=b6%2fLEVHqrBP6hrOBOI75HFmYAqHw2CVN9LhY7dL4N2s%3d

If you can know the price down a bit this might also be a good choice:
www.seabreeze.com.au/Classifieds/Windsurfing/Sails/~b12xk/2007-Gaastra-Remedy-64-metre.aspx?search=b6%2fLEVHqrBP6hrOBOI75HFmYAqHw2CVN9LhY7dL4N2s%3d

There are plenty around, just a case of finding the right one. Different sails need different masts and booms so I'd suggest finding a sail that works and then seeing if there is a good boom and mast to suit. I've got a 5.3 that you could have cheapish but I think that might be a bit small for you in Sydney winds.

OK, others have held off saying it but I would probably look to sell on the gear you bought, its going to really slow the learning curve. Sorry, I know you don't want to hear that. Did you tell the guy you bought it from that you were a beginner? If so it was a bit harsh of him to sell it to you. (sorry if I've just offended someone on this forum).

Starting off can be a bit of a minefield gearwise but it will be well worth it!!!!



i would not worry about the offense, if that was the case you are right. selling a beginner that gear would put them of windsurfing for life. if i had to sail a formula board and 10.7 i'd give up.
dougr
dougr
NSW
34 posts
NSW, 34 posts
30 Aug 2011 1:59pm
I'm kinda f*cked with replacing the gear straight away as i literally just bought it (not cheap, and am light on coinage for sails etc).

I've spoken to the awesome people at Wind Surf n Snow and am going to take the mast and sail down on Saturday to seem if they can do me any "exchange plus cash" deals on a new sail/mast combo.

the board will probably stay, whether it slows me down or not for the next little while as budget will enforce this
felixdcat
felixdcat
WA
3519 posts
WA, 3519 posts
30 Aug 2011 12:45pm
What is the board?
DunkO
DunkO
NSW
1150 posts
NSW, 1150 posts
30 Aug 2011 2:55pm
you will still be able to get around on the board its just not going to be ideal to progress further on easily.
Waiting4wind
Waiting4wind
NSW
1871 posts
NSW, 1871 posts
30 Aug 2011 3:03pm
dougr said...

I'm kinda f*cked with replacing the gear straight away as i literally just bought it (not cheap, and am light on coinage for sails etc).

I've spoken to the awesome people at Wind Surf n Snow and am going to take the mast and sail down on Saturday to seem if they can do me any "exchange plus cash" deals on a new sail/mast combo.

the board will probably stay, whether it slows me down or not for the next little while as budget will enforce this


Take the board down to WSS as well, they make be able to give you some pointers on setting it up for a frendlier ride and maybe look at fin options.
Jezstrt
Jezstrt
TAS
1471 posts
TAS, 1471 posts
30 Aug 2011 3:16pm
jh2703 said...

Don't know if your ready to throw some coin at the sport...but you will end up doing so, I saw this one on eBay and it's a good deal...everything you need.

http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/starboard-go-windsurfing-setup-/230663855946?pt=AU_Sport_Surfing&hash=item35b4a31f4a#ht_600wt_922

Cheers.


That's a good package deal for someone that's windsurfed a few times already on a bit larger gear!
dougr
dougr
NSW
34 posts
NSW, 34 posts
30 Aug 2011 6:42pm

Take the board down to WSS as well, they make be able to give you some pointers on setting it up for a frendlier ride and maybe look at fin options.


Great idea - if the weather is good i'll do just that :)
confused
confused
NSW
175 posts
NSW, 175 posts
30 Aug 2011 8:21pm


Take all the gear, whatever the weather. They might be able to do a wholesale trade in for different gear and are very likely to be able to tweak things around for you.

dougr
dougr
NSW
34 posts
NSW, 34 posts
31 Aug 2011 11:08pm
what do you think the chance of me having any fun if i keep the formula board (without a dagger board/fin) and replace my sail?

really need to figure out if i just stop and resell and my cost price all the gear and start again or take advantage of the board (appears to be very nice - its an f2 fx100) and just sail down
Waiting4wind
Waiting4wind
NSW
1871 posts
NSW, 1871 posts
31 Aug 2011 11:42pm
dougr said...

what do you think the chance of me having any fun if i keep the formula board (without a dagger board/fin) and replace my sail?

really need to figure out if i just stop and resell and my cost price all the gear and start again or take advantage of the board (appears to be very nice - its an f2 fx100) and just sail down


Formula boards like big sails and big fins to make them work right, ie. sailing on the plane. Once you do get it on the plane they work well going up wind and going down wind (challenging for a beginner). They're no so good going across the wind which will be the prefered angle for a beginner / intermediate. The straps are a long way outboard and difficult to get into without good technique.

To make matters worse (for a beginner) they're not much fun off the plane. You could try a smaller fin and try to retrofit some extra straps - more inboard to make it more friendly.

Go to WSS and have a chat with Sam Parker. He knows formula boards inside out and has sailed most of them. He should be able to give you good advice on making the board usable for your needs.

Having said this, at the end of the day, you will have a much better experience and opportunity to progress on some free ride gear. So if you can trade the gear for something more user friendly then you would be much better off.
Jezstrt
Jezstrt
TAS
1471 posts
TAS, 1471 posts
1 Sep 2011 12:08am
Waiting4wind said...

Having said this, at the end of the day, you will have a much better experience and opportunity to progress on some free ride gear. So if you can trade the gear for something more user friendly then you would be much better off.


+1
dougr
dougr
NSW
34 posts
NSW, 34 posts
1 Sep 2011 11:38am
should have really waited... my original post around what gear i should get was focused more on the displacement of the board not the type, so i've really dug myself a hole...
confused
confused
NSW
175 posts
NSW, 175 posts
1 Sep 2011 12:52pm


Wouldn't worry too much, your best bet might be to split the items and sell them on here separately, can take a few weeks but you'll get it shifted.

As waitingforwind says, freeride gear is the way forward. Its a bit of a pain but we've all bought the wrong gear at some point.

The other thing to consider is that unless you are considerably better than most beginners your mast will do have a lot of encounters with the front of the board, much better off to do that on fairly tough freeride board than a formula board.

dougr
dougr
NSW
34 posts
NSW, 34 posts
5 Sep 2011 5:07pm
I have to add a comment because i'm that bloody happy with the service i received from Wind, Surf & Snow in Collaroy.

I basically swapped my mast, mast extension, boom, and sail for a second hand sail in near-new condition, a brand new mast, a brand new boom and brand new mast extension and mast guard for minimal dollars.

I understand that i probably swapped carbon everything for cheaper gear, but the ease of the transaction, the staff's happiness to take on the risk of not selling my gear and the knowledge about everything that was imparted at the same time == MAJORLY WINNING

Cannot be happier - will definitely be buying gear from them again, which will probably be soon from my personal experiences with impulse buying :)

Now lets hope the wind and sun come out next weekend the way the did this weekend in Sydney
Samuellae
Samuellae
NSW
59 posts
NSW, 59 posts
23 Oct 2011 2:07pm
Hey all,
I'm in a pretty similar to this fellow (douga)- been windsurfing a few times and getting the hang of it more and more~
The gang at longy set me up with a second hand 5.4 North sail, new mast (430cm) and new boom for under a grand, which I use on a 145 Litre F2 'power glide CSE' (8'10 ft/269 x 73.8cm) with a 44cm Maui fin.

It rigs up pretty nicely, but is it normal to have to pull the out and down haul so tight to have it so the battens shift past the mast easily? even when I pull it all as tight as i'm willing to (or able to for that matter) there still seems to be some looseness around the boom height of the mast- which is making the battens 'stick' when tacking.
Should I just suck it up and try and get it all tighter?

Speaking of tacking and the gibe, i'm struggling with that a bit- i can get goin nicly in a good wind cos I have surfed and sailed cats for ages- but its a different story when it comes time to turning (i'm sporting a black and blue nose from a mast to the face on friday :S)...i really need to book in for the learn to windsurf series haha.

anyway I'm thinking of getting a bigger board-
and I like the idea of a formula board for light winds-
so my next question is:
If I plan to end up sailing with a proper formula set up (big sails and all)
is it a good idea to get a formula board to learn on?

i've seen the starboard learning stuff, but i figure if a formula board is a similar size and stability then why not get one?

If this was a good idea does anyone have a post-2003 one around they want to liquidate?

thanks for any suggestions!

off to Botany this arvo if anyone's around!

Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
23 Oct 2011 1:36pm
Don't do it!!!
If you are still learning to gybe the F2 there is no way you will be able to gybe a formula. People who are very competent gybers feel like they are re-learning wen going to a formula.

Plus it will completely ruin your experience of going for the straps when planing (the Starboard learner's gear you refer to has inboard and forward strap setings so that is OK but a Formula does not)

Plus the long long fin may restrict you depending on where u sail (although a plus is it will force you to waterstart not beach start lol)

Plus they are fragile as, and you will destroy it when learning to gybe, waterstart and forward loop

BarryFawkes
BarryFawkes
NSW
149 posts
NSW, 149 posts
23 Oct 2011 4:43pm
Sam if you can surf and sail cats you wont have much trouble with a formula board a good sall around 7,5 to 8 meters to start with .formula boards dont need huge sails we use the big sails to point higher or sail lower when racing.a few saturdays at marmong or on botany with the formula fleet for instruction will do wonders I still use an 8 when racing in strong wind as do many in my division
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
23 Oct 2011 1:59pm
Sorry Barry I disagree. The reason they make freeride boards is they are easier to carve gybe and more accessable for recreational sailing.
The reson they make Formula is to race - go as fast as possible and go up and down wind really well but at the expense of user friendliness.
Learning to gybe well on a formula would be ridiculously frustrating compared to a freeride board.

The first thing an intermediate will do is go flat out across the wind and try to go for the straps which are near on impossible to reach.

You advice is fine for somebody who is at the stage where they can plane in the straps and harness, and maybe make some of their gybes with carving through most of it and dropping off the plane at the exit, but not falling off in gybes. That kind "upper intermediate" level
Samuellae does not sound like he is at that level when saying he's been windsurfing a few times

BarryFawkes
BarryFawkes
NSW
149 posts
NSW, 149 posts
23 Oct 2011 5:54pm
Mark if I lived in lancalin I would agree but the wind over here is a bit lighter than the west, Forula boards are light fast and manouvarable also stable. They dont jybe as well as a freeride but on a reach in light wind they go quite well. Wehave had a small number of people rock up to the club with little or no windsurfing experience and have progressed quite well my daughter planed for the first time on my board and loves it. Also there is a large formula fleet over here with a number of clubs organised events and coaching for newcomers mayby sam might even have a race sometime with us but the option is there
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅