Windsurfers and Kiters Safety Bay

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
WA66
WA66
WA
138 posts
WA, 138 posts
15 May 2009 11:50am
Can anyone clarify for me the article on the front of todays local paper - Weekend Courier 15th May 2009. It states there will be designated areas in Safety Bay for Windsurfers and Kiters.
That is each will have their own area to rig up at, launch from and where to sail.
Can anyone tell me exactly where those areas are?
Thanks.
Paul
Paul
WA
346 posts
WA, 346 posts
15 May 2009 4:58pm
Hi Micheal
Kiters can now rig up in the yacht club car park and kite on the road. Once they have all been cleaned up by cars the intermediate and beginner windsurfers can have their "SAFE" easy entry to ocean sailing, learner location back, without the threat of death by kite strings.

One of the safest learner locations close to Perth other than the river has been ruined by the kiters. Now the advanced sailors can sail out in the bay, but the intermediates are now forced into the bottom corner of the pond with barely enough room for gybing let alone 5 or 6 sailors in there as well. You can blame the euro tourists this season and the schools that teach in the top corner.
lotofwind
lotofwind
NSW
6451 posts
NSW, 6451 posts
15 May 2009 8:32pm
another case of natural selection,survival of the fittest,evolution.
Its like in nature,the weak runts of the litter get pushed to the bottom and eventually become extinct,while the fitter,stronger creature thrives.
The cycle of nature.
Evolve or become extinct.
Mother nature is cruel,but fair.

trollen
WA Surf
WA Surf
WA
336 posts
WA, 336 posts
15 May 2009 7:53pm
I attended meetings with City of Rockingham, DEC, DPI, WAKSA, WWA, SBYC and SBWC over the summer, I have a draft map of the proposals in the shop if you would like to come and look at it, you will need to call ahead however as we are not there unless it is windy at the moment.

I do want to point out that there are no schools that teach in the top corner or any part of the pond, we are the only licenced school for that area and have for years operated on the north-west side on the sand spit and educate all beginners we come into contact with to do likewise. You will find that any teaching/learning going on in the pond is the general public or maybe the odd rogue operator.

My understanding is that DPI is currently working on draft signage for the area, but it has been some months since I have last heard from them.

The on water designation was effectively the top (windward in s/w) third/half to be reserved for kitesurfers and closer to the road for windsurfers then rigging area's would reflect the on water areas. It was acknowledged that having the kitesurfers upwind of the windsurfers defied common practice, but also that it did seem to be reality in the area and signage was to stress that the pond area was only for experienced kiters who would have the skills to stick to their designated area.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
15 May 2009 9:53pm
WA Surf said...

.........that the pond area was only for experienced kiters who would have the skills to stick to their designated area.


From what I have seen, most of the Perth flatwater kiter crew seem to think they belong in the expert "I can kite close to people cos I'm kewwwl" category
A sign stating that the area is only for experts will be like a red rag to a bull?

lotofwind
lotofwind
NSW
6451 posts
NSW, 6451 posts
16 May 2009 12:32am
red thumb away.but you all know its true.

you cant stop the natural progression.

Time to face the facts,stop living in the past.

Dinos became extinct.............

You cant stop the nature of the beast.


trollen

grumplestiltskin
grumplestiltskin
WA
2331 posts
WA, 2331 posts
15 May 2009 10:58pm
lotofwind said...

red thumb away.but you all know its true.

you cant stop the natural progression.

Time to face the facts,stop living in the past.

Dinos became extinct.............

You cant stop the nature of the beast.


trollen




its an unfortunate fact that d i c kheads are found in every sport
NotWal
NotWal
QLD
7436 posts
QLD, 7436 posts
16 May 2009 1:01am
lotofwind said...

red thumb away.but you all know its true.

you cant stop the natural progression.

Time to face the facts,stop living in the past.

Dinos became extinct.............

You cant stop the nature of the beast.


trollen


Breathing's a pretty archaic pass time. Perhaps you'd care to stop.


NowindSurfer
NowindSurfer
WA
163 posts
WA, 163 posts
15 May 2009 11:30pm
Mark _australia said...

WA Surf said...

.........that the pond area was only for experienced kiters who would have the skills to stick to their designated area.


From what I have seen, most of the Perth flatwater kiter crew seem to think they belong in the expert "I can kite close to people cos I'm kewwwl" category
A sign stating that the area is only for experts will be like a red rag to a bull?




What is indirect discrimination?
Indirect discrimination is often less obvious. Sometimes, a policy, rule or practice seems fair because it applies to everyone equally, but a closer look shows that some people are being treated unfairly. This is because some people or groups of people, are unable or less able to comply with the rule or are disadvantaged because of it. If this policy or practice is 'not reasonable', it may be indirect discrimination.
NowindSurfer
NowindSurfer
WA
163 posts
WA, 163 posts
15 May 2009 11:32pm
WA Surf said...

I attended meetings with City of Rockingham, DEC, DPI, WAKSA, WWA, SBYC and SBWC over the summer, I have a draft map of the proposals in the shop if you would like to come and look at it, you will need to call ahead however as we are not there unless it is windy at the moment.

I do want to point out that there are no schools that teach in the top corner or any part of the pond, we are the only licenced school for that area and have for years operated on the north-west side on the sand spit and educate all beginners we come into contact with to do likewise. You will find that any teaching/learning going on in the pond is the general public or maybe the odd rogue operator.

My understanding is that DPI is currently working on draft signage for the area, but it has been some months since I have last heard from them.

The on water designation was effectively the top (windward in s/w) third/half to be reserved for kitesurfers and closer to the road for windsurfers then rigging area's would reflect the on water areas. It was acknowledged that having the kitesurfers upwind of the windsurfers defied common practice, but also that it did seem to be reality in the area and signage was to stress that the pond area was only for experienced kiters who would have the skills to stick to their designated area.


What is indirect discrimination?
Indirect discrimination is often less obvious. Sometimes, a policy, rule or practice seems fair because it applies to everyone equally, but a closer look shows that some people are being treated unfairly. This is because some people or groups of people, are unable or less able to comply with the rule or are disadvantaged because of it. If this policy or practice is 'not reasonable', it may be indirect discrimination.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
15 May 2009 11:36pm
Nice cut'n'paste from the equal opportunities commission website or similar, but what exactly is your point regarding kiters and windsurfers getting along?
NowindSurfer
NowindSurfer
WA
163 posts
WA, 163 posts
15 May 2009 11:49pm
I dont think they could quite make up rules for the area mark but they can sygest it.
In my experience on a busy Saturday afternoon in summer when i was learning the pool area was extremely busy. Not being able to windsurf that good i found myself in danger when i was stuck in the middle of some extremely fast moving windsurfers and kite surfers.
On the return pass from the outer wikikki to the pengunin island side of the pool on both sandbanks in the late afternoon can clouded with porr visability leading to effected judgement due to the sun reflection.

I would promote the idea and have been in the situation where i was to in experienced to be in such a high traffic area.
I think alot of new people kitesurfers are sticking to sandbank of to the point of the pool with windsufrere sticking to to run from the jetty to the pool along the shore.

I dont believe they need signs as it would only take a short time for anyone being stuck in the center continually to work out it wasnt a safe place to hang around.

I think the grassed area that is there already is good just some wanker keeps on stealing the hose connector on the tap.
Windxtasy
Windxtasy
WA
4019 posts
WA, 4019 posts
16 May 2009 10:09am
NowindSurfer said...

I dont think they could quite make up rules for the area mark but they can sygest it.
In my experience on a busy Saturday afternoon in summer when i was learning the pool area was extremely busy. Not being able to windsurf that good i found myself in danger when i was stuck in the middle of some extremely fast moving windsurfers and kite surfers.
On the return pass from the outer wikikki to the pengunin island side of the pool on both sandbanks in the late afternoon can clouded with porr visability leading to effected judgement due to the sun reflection.

I would promote the idea and have been in the situation where i was to in experienced to be in such a high traffic area.
I think alot of new people kitesurfers are sticking to sandbank of to the point of the pool with windsufrere sticking to to run from the jetty to the pool along the shore.

I dont believe they need signs as it would only take a short time for anyone being stuck in the center continually to work out it wasnt a safe place to hang around.

I think the grassed area that is there already is good just some wanker keeps on stealing the hose connector on the tap.



I agree.
On the occasions I have sailed there it was kiters to windward (sandspit) and sailboarders reaching from the beach near the jetty carpark past the jetty to the sandbank. A natural division for comfort and safety, with a bit of a buffer zone in the middle.

Obviously there must have been some problems or legislation would have been unnecessary.

So just what are the new guidelines?
Does anyone know?

I love Safety Bay and I am planning to holiday there next summer.
I hope they haven't spoiled it for windsurfers.

and ditto about the hose connector!

knots
knots
WA
114 posts
WA, 114 posts
16 May 2009 11:13am
To all windsurfers who have sailed safety bay for the last 35 years.I would not be concerned with proposal.The wind dynamics will dictate the terms through wind velocity , wind direction and surface chop.SSW wind 18 knots plus will make it very difficult for the kiters to maintain position.The kite techology has not been developed to harness those conditions.
Under WA tort law no court will up hold duty of care if a wind powered water kite is up wind and involved in a non zero harm incident.
Windsurfers relax.There will be a report released in the near future on kiting impact on tern island.
used2surf
used2surf
WA
47 posts
WA, 47 posts
16 May 2009 9:48pm
Just like to point out that if we're talking about natural progression and that sort of thing, jet skis and f====ing big motor boats will sort out all of us if we keep fighting, oh and another thought the average sail board is a hell of a lot bigger and harder than the average kiter so get outa tha way ! On another note thats three kiters Ive rescued so far and where I come from we seem to get on ok, oh yes I've been beaned on the head a few times by out of control kites but they scare more than hurt. Cheers we are going to have to learn to get on afterall Bob
jaymac
jaymac
WA
44 posts
WA, 44 posts
19 May 2009 10:27am
I cannot understand what the fuss is about, I ended up sailing lots around the pond this year, when the shark scared me out of the deep sound! Even with 20 odd windsurfers and 25 kites it always seems reasonably safe, with a bit of routine to the high speed movements.
It struck me that no sailor could complain about congestion, each chose to sail there, they must like it! There is such a lot of underused water space from Point Peron to Port Kennedy, ideal for kites and windsurfers, why do they all sail in one spot?
There is no need for rules and signs, just a simple message.
Caveat pengo......user beware!
Windxtasy
Windxtasy
WA
4019 posts
WA, 4019 posts
19 May 2009 11:52am
jaymac said...


Caveat pengo



Does that mean "Give Way To Penguins?"

FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15100 posts
WA, 15100 posts
19 May 2009 12:40pm
Windxtasy said...

jaymac said...


Caveat pengo



Does that mean "Give Way To Penguins?"




Beware the hungry penguin?
poor relative
poor relative
WA
9106 posts
WA, 9106 posts
19 May 2009 1:28pm
knots said...

The wind dynamics will dictate the terms through wind velocity , wind direction and surface chop.SSW wind 18 knots plus will make it very difficult for the kiters to maintain position.The kite techology has not been developed to harness those conditions.


Biggest WTF i've seen for yonks.....
Windxtasy
Windxtasy
WA
4019 posts
WA, 4019 posts
19 May 2009 3:37pm
FormulaNova said...

Windxtasy said...

jaymac said...


Caveat pengo



Does that mean "Give Way To Penguins?"




Beware the hungry penguin?


It's beware the hungry shark at Safety Bay!

FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15100 posts
WA, 15100 posts
19 May 2009 4:24pm
Windxtasy said...

FormulaNova said...

Windxtasy said...

jaymac said...


Caveat pengo



Does that mean "Give Way To Penguins?"




Beware the hungry penguin?


It's beware the hungry shark at Safety Bay!




Nah, the 'Hungry Penguin' is a fish and chip shop at Safety Bay. I was going to ask for white pointer and chips, but I thought better of it...
Danger Mouse
Danger Mouse
WA
592 posts
WA, 592 posts
20 May 2009 4:15pm
poor relative said...

knots said...

The wind dynamics will dictate the terms through wind velocity , wind direction and surface chop.SSW wind 18 knots plus will make it very difficult for the kiters to maintain position.The kite techology has not been developed to harness those conditions.


Biggest WTF i've seen for yonks.....


With you on that one Relli

D
Danger Mouse
Danger Mouse
WA
592 posts
WA, 592 posts
20 May 2009 4:19pm
used2surf said...

Just like to point out that if we're talking about natural progression and that sort of thing, jet skis and f====ing big motor boats will sort out all of us if we keep fighting, oh and another thought the average sail board is a hell of a lot bigger and harder than the average kiter so get outa tha way ! On another note thats three kiters Ive rescued so far and where I come from we seem to get on ok, oh yes I've been beaned on the head a few times by out of control kites but they scare more than hurt. Cheers we are going to have to learn to get on afterall Bob


Couldn't agree more used2surf, I'm a kiter, my old man's a windsurfer and we manage not to kill each other, so it's obvious that it's possible. I think it's just a fact that there are a certain amount of oxygen thieves in any collective group of people, no matter what group that may be.

D
Richiefish
Richiefish
QLD
5612 posts
QLD, 5612 posts
20 May 2009 6:50pm
I dont think our kiters here in QLD are as "....." as the ones over there in WA...
firiebob
firiebob
WA
3182 posts
WA, 3182 posts
20 May 2009 7:52pm
Richiefish said...

I dont think our kiters here in QLD are as "....." as the ones over there in WA...


Certainly no problem in FNQ where windsurfers are way out numbered by kitesurfers
used2surf
used2surf
WA
47 posts
WA, 47 posts
20 May 2009 9:01pm
Just another thought even Robbie Naish Sails and Kites and now b---er me he even rides a SUP . Now an SUP with a sail track, I could handle that!, and I just remembered seeing a guy ride a Mal with a kite. Takes every kind of people to make the world ya ya ya you all know the song. Bob
FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15100 posts
WA, 15100 posts
22 May 2009 7:29pm
firiebob said...

Richiefish said...

I dont think our kiters here in QLD are as "....." as the ones over there in WA...


Certainly no problem in FNQ where windsurfers are way out numbered by kitesurfers


I am not keen on the idea of kiting, but even I would see the benefit in being able to boost out of the way if you come across a croc. I went to Yorkey's about 4 years ago and there was a single windsurfer amongst about 30 kiters.
NowindSurfer
NowindSurfer
WA
163 posts
WA, 163 posts
22 May 2009 8:06pm
apart from saftey
A large advantage of keeping together is that it drives people to be better and push the limits.
People learn off other people.
Its not showing off its an invitation to push yourself harder.

That why people go to the same spot.

the pool is also surrounded by sandbanks and is extremely calm in windy conditions
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅