Using aluminium extensions with 100% carbon masts

7 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Orange Whip
Orange Whip
QLD
1080 posts
QLD, 1080 posts
8 Mar 2019 7:28pm
I've recently begun upgrading my masts to 90-100% carbon content, having experienced first-hand enormous benefits that make the extra cost worthwhile. As an average Joe freerider I have no intention of buying carbon extensions due to their high cost, but I was just wondering whether there is potential to damage a carbon mast when using it with an aluminium extension?

I assume that an aluminium extension is 100% rigid with no flex. I also assume that an advantage of a carbon extension when used in conjunction with a carbon mast is that it will flex, hence perfecting the curvature of the full length of the mast how it was intended, to maximise the performance of the sail.

Does the bottom 20-30 cm of a carbon mast flex? Does a carbon mast extension flex? If they do flex is there potential for damage using an extension that presumably doesn't flex?
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
8 Mar 2019 5:31pm
Both will flex but I think the ally will flex a lot more.
sailquik
sailquik
VIC
6171 posts
VIC, 6171 posts
8 Mar 2019 8:37pm
It's just not a problem. Been using alloy extensions and 100% carbon masts for years.

RDM or SDM? Don't think it matters anyhow.........
Orange Whip
Orange Whip
QLD
1080 posts
QLD, 1080 posts
8 Mar 2019 7:39pm
Ah righto, thanks gents, nothing to worry about.
Paducah
Paducah
2833 posts
2833 posts
8 Mar 2019 9:44pm
All the answers above are correct. Also, bending forces are the least on the ends, the most in the middle. Almost all the force on an extension is in compression (downhaul). Think about it: bridges (sticks, toothpicks, etc.) fail in the middle, not the ends.
Farang
Farang
43 posts
43 posts
8 Mar 2019 9:52pm
Alu ext is good - will not snap like a Carbon ext - you can still sail back home though it would be bent, but with snapped Carbon it is gonna be a swimming case. And Alu likes Carbon - so no worries .
forceten
forceten
1312 posts
1312 posts
8 Mar 2019 11:20pm
sailquik said..
It's just not a problem. Been using alloy extensions and 100% carbon masts for years.

RDM or SDM? Don't think it matters anyhow.........


What he said.

write this dude.

[email protected]
choco
choco
SA
4181 posts
SA, 4181 posts
9 Mar 2019 10:32am
Farang said..
Alu ext is good - will not snap like a Carbon ext - you can still sail back home though it would be bent, but with snapped Carbon it is gonna be a swimming case. And Alu likes Carbon - so no worries .


Spot on Farang! I had a big crash and snapped my carbon RDM extansion luckily I could walk back instead of swimming in the sea.
yoyo
yoyo
WA
1646 posts
WA, 1646 posts
9 Mar 2019 8:16am
Ditto,
Carbon looks cool but ally cheaper and more reliable... bugger all weight difference and it is in a location where it doesn't matter anyway.
sausage
sausage
QLD
4874 posts
QLD, 4874 posts
9 Mar 2019 10:31am
Never had a carbon break on me, but had both SDM & RDM aluminium extensions snap in half. (I qualify this by saying the extensions both had excessive chalking /corrosion at one length I had it set at fairly consistently). Carbon can /does induce galvanic corrosion in aluminium but all in all it's not a major concern.

BTW Still could sail the board even if with some difficulty (although it did damage inside of mast sleeve at base)
jusavina
jusavina
QLD
1504 posts
QLD, 1504 posts
9 Mar 2019 8:52pm
Never leave your extension in the mast for storage though.
Corrosion will occurs and damage the mast.
Waiting4wind
Waiting4wind
NSW
1871 posts
NSW, 1871 posts
11 Mar 2019 9:05pm
jusavina said..
Never leave your extension in the mast for storage though.
Corrosion will occurs and damage the mast.


Yep, even after leaving my gear rigged for a long weekend the Alu extension came out of mast slightly pitted, ie. small corrosion spots all over it.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅