The end of Maui

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
mkseven
mkseven
QLD
2315 posts
QLD, 2315 posts
23 Oct 2007 7:41pm
First the reduction in rentals.

Now a 10 man surfing rule where windsurfers can't sail.

Read and watch the vid here:
mauisurfreport.blogspot.com/2007/10/saddest-day-at-hookipa.html

Damn fun police.

For me at least Maui was a definite once in a life trip to live the hype, but now? For sure there are lots of great places to sail on the island, but there are lots of great places to sail everywhere that cost half as much to enjoy. I guess WA will be becoming alot more popular now.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
23 Oct 2007 5:52pm
quote:
Originally posted by mkseven


I guess WA will be becoming alot more popular now.



Yeah, thanks
WindWarrior
WindWarrior
NSW
1019 posts
NSW, 1019 posts
23 Oct 2007 8:01pm
A very very sad day indeed

Respect to Josh Stone for at least trying to get the police to return the gear they confiscated from the tourist who got caught up in this crap fight.

A few of us have been lucky enough to sail this magical spot and hope that sense will prevail meaning more people will be able to do the same.


Al McLeod
Al McLeod
VIC
633 posts
VIC, 633 posts
23 Oct 2007 8:22pm
its total crap. now british airways has is refusing to take windsurfing equipment as well.
Richiefish
Richiefish
QLD
5612 posts
QLD, 5612 posts
23 Oct 2007 10:07pm
sounds like a nice place full of ****ers. Too many of them ! Hostile locals suck.As do cocky tourists.
snides8
snides8
WA
1731 posts
WA, 1731 posts
23 Oct 2007 8:44pm
'Team America' all over again
Haircut
Haircut
QLD
6491 posts
QLD, 6491 posts
23 Oct 2007 10:58pm
Ho'okipa? Bah - who needs it. We got The'Train man
sick_em_rex
sick_em_rex
NSW
1601 posts
NSW, 1601 posts
23 Oct 2007 11:26pm
One thing that continually makes me feel good about our sport is the fact that WHENEVER you see or meet another windsurfer on the water, beach, carpark looking for wind, whatever, thay are ALWAYS friendly and welcoming. I have lost count of how many posts I have read on here where people have offered places to stay to complete strangers as they may be venturing interstate and want to sail somewhere they have never been or at the very worst an offer to show them around their local break or speed run or lake. What continues to DISGUST me is the pathetic tribal culture that goes from one surf break to another perpetuated by the surfers who surf within. Whilst I know quite probably the vast majority of surfers are great people and couldn't give two hoots as to who surfs there, there is always a rogue element that just taints it for everyone else associated within. A classic case is Josh Stone in that video making reference to the guys out surfing most likely on welfare and yet here he is, works hard for a living and pays a shed load of taxes (like I presume most of the windsurfers on the planet otherwise how else can we afford to buy our gear), and yet his rights to windsurf are being undermined by someone who doesn't even contribute to society. I know that is a massive generalisation and a comment not based on fact at all but you would all have to agree there is some truth to it in some way.
It saddens me to think that the authorities in Maui/Hookipa have let it progress to this. It is a sad endightment on society that this has happened. I just hope sanity prevails and that something gets sorted out soon. I have very fond memories of seeing the Aloha Classic at Hookipa back in 1991 and I'm glad I'm not hanging my hat on ever seeing it again. Judging by what's happening I wouldn't have anywhere to stay while I was there anyway and even I did the contest might get shut down by the fun police
By the way, I surf too so I'm not anti surfers.
snides8
snides8
WA
1731 posts
WA, 1731 posts
23 Oct 2007 9:50pm
nicely put sic-em!
if this sort of policing/bizzare rule making can happen in the (so called)'LAND OF THE FREE' what hope have we got here?
stehsegler
stehsegler
WA
3571 posts
WA, 3571 posts
23 Oct 2007 11:41pm
quote:
british airways has is refusing to take windsurfing equipment as well.



BA has always been bad with excess luggage. I once got stranded with 70 kg of luggage on the way back from Australia to Germany because BA wouldn't take my gear despite the fact that they were all to happy to take it the other way.

Another friend of mine once flew out from a World Cup in Japan with a lot of gear in tow. After long arguments with BA they finally agreed to take the gear at US$70 per kilo. He ended up dumbing everything which was to heavy into a bin and told his sponsor back home the gear had been stolen from his rental car.

Hence always check with the airline before you book the flight!

RE Maui... well that was just a matter of time. Sad but true... the crazy thing is when you go to other places like the NSW South Coast or Baja California you pretty much sail alone most of the time. Both areas can be consistent if you go at the right time...

Personally I'll take WA over Maui anytime... they do better beer there too.
555
555
892 posts
555 555
892 posts
24 Oct 2007 5:19am
Maui seems to be having a PR nightmare..

How many decades has it taken to build up the tourist industry to what it was before the rental crack down? And now, even if you do find somewhere to stay, you can't sail anyway..

I can understand it from the local's perspective though - they've been over-run by overweight, loud, arrogant americans.. That'd get on my nerve as well. It doesn't take too many pushy americans and aggro euro sailors to give me a bad case of 'push off back to where you came from'.

Don't get me wrong, I've met some nice euro sailors, and some very pleasant americans, but as always, it's the minority that spoils things for the masses.

Meanwhile Jeri (Brazil) is in the middle of a massive advertising campaign involving free DVD ISOs, two-weekly video diaries etc. etc.

I know where I'd be planning to spend my overseas holiday budget(if I had one?!)
dan berry
dan berry
WA
2562 posts
WA, 2562 posts
24 Oct 2007 5:23am
hey guys,
I was at hookipa that day and saw it all go down. First of all the 10 surfers in the water rule over there has been around for years, it just seems to have worked beter in the past. Usually it all works pretty smoothe, at 11am the trades start to fillin and the surfers either get out or start paddling up towards middles, as it gets stronger the move up to pavillions. On that particular day I counted around 40 surfers at the point and this was at 1pm and it was windy as hell. Another point about that day was it had been flat ( I mean flaaaaaaaat) for the previous couple of weeks and very little south swells over summer so they were all pretty deperate for a wave. I also noticed that alot of the surfers werent locals, which is what josh's beef was about.
Apparently the lifeguard tower has contributed to the tensions due to the fact that the lifeguard that "runs" the beach is a surfer so his opinion is a bit bias when it comes to conflict resolution.
Oh and if you think it was entertaining on you tube, you should have seen what happened in the carpark afterwards,, keep yours eyes out on you tube Im sure it will pop up.
sick_em_rex
sick_em_rex
NSW
1601 posts
NSW, 1601 posts
24 Oct 2007 9:17am
Dan would you mind posting the you tube link if it does happen to show up and we may have missed it.
Thanks for the insight
DavMen
DavMen
NSW
1510 posts
NSW, 1510 posts
24 Oct 2007 9:32am
Spot on Sick_em_rex.

In my youth I was a full on surfer couldn't get enough of it! before work/school, after, and instead off. But the agro in the water ended up geting the better of me and I finally gave it away.
Luckily I discovered windsurfing and to my memory have never meet an agro sailor, infact quite the opposite - even the locals come up to you and strike up a conversation and welcome you to their haven.
In surfing this is not the case, hostile, teritorial, and alouf. Sad but true!

DavMen
divaldo
divaldo
SA
2878 posts
SA, 2878 posts
24 Oct 2007 9:06am
As Giampaolo said on his blog, things have calmed down a bit since Sunday. The 10 surfer rule has always been in place, just always been a gentlemens(womens) agreement that come 11am, wind kicks in Surfers move out. When you have 2000 tourists rocking up everyday, not sure of exact figures, but would imagine it would be huge, many of them surfers, sailors, kiters etc and they all want a piece of the island, they are eventually going get in each others way!

I know that I wont be sailing at Hookipa next year, will opt for the roomy surrounds of Kanaha

Group hug everyone!




JEFFERSON
JEFFERSON
WA
72 posts
WA, 72 posts
24 Oct 2007 11:03am
It is a sad state of affairs that the tension at Hookipa is the way it is. There has always been a lot of tension at the Pavillions end of the carpark, just driving through there used to be a hassle.

I can't imagine however that it was local surfers staying out in the water at that time. The Hawaiins way may be aggressive at times but they are a respectful bunch and once you have their respect they are generally really cool people, and in general they always had respect for good sailors who also had a bit of etiquette.

As for the point people have made about how bad this is for their economy, I don't think their authorities give a crap. I mean compare the amount of tourists that go to Maui for other reasons other than windsurfing at Hookipa. The whole west side of the island is full of resorts and condo's. The percentage of people who stay in private rentals on the north shore is just a pee in the ocean compared to the numbers of tourist that fill those places year round.

The percentage of windsurfing tourist that go to Maui to sail Hookipa is extremely low when compared to the greater mass of windsurfing tourists that go to bump and jump sail at the lower reefs, & the percentage of windsurfers to over all tourism is also small. So unfortunately it will boil down to the loacl authorities showing some thoughfulness and maybe legislating the 11am rule and or getting a new life guard.

Thats my 2 bobs worth.

Ps - The lifeguard that used to work at Kanaha years ago was excellent. When the swell was too big for Hookipa and lower Kanaha was around mast high he would spend the whole day on his jet ski towing broken down windurfers back into the beach.
NR
NR
WA
517 posts
NR NR
WA, 517 posts
24 Oct 2007 11:32am
Jefferson. I hear you. I had a ride back on a big day in the middle of winter with that lifeguard when I had bust my mast a few kms out and right down wind. He had seen me go down there to investigate the waves so he decided to follow, and with that, on the first set, mast went. he was on hand to tow me and my gear back in. was high 5s on the way as he loved it that he could whip in the middle of the sets, and we a grin ear to ear and me hanging off the rescue board with all my gear crunched up on the back could get out of the zone. Was funny as.

dan berry
dan berry
WA
2562 posts
WA, 2562 posts
24 Oct 2007 5:50pm
The funny thing I found this year was that up a pavillions it seemed to be waaaay different, you still had the HGA crew up there but there were also tourists having picinics and so forth. So dofferent from the old days. I remember having rocks and spear guns being shot ay your cars, now theres picinics going on.
But at least you knew that once you ran the gauntlet thru pavillions back then at least you could sail at the point.
Fast Eddy
Fast Eddy
NSW
174 posts
NSW, 174 posts
26 Oct 2007 7:57pm
I just got back from maui this afternoon, what a bad vibe.
I don't think I'll be going back.....
dan berry
dan berry
WA
2562 posts
WA, 2562 posts
26 Oct 2007 6:10pm
hey ed,
how was the rest of the trip??
Fast Eddy
Fast Eddy
NSW
174 posts
NSW, 174 posts
26 Oct 2007 8:15pm
Waves smaller then the wind backed off for a day, then blasted again.
The whole experience left me appreciating what we have here, cant wait for some south coast lines soon....
dan berry
dan berry
WA
2562 posts
WA, 2562 posts
26 Oct 2007 6:20pm
Funny you should say that, I got off the plane grabbed a coffee put all the gear back together and went down to wanda, had just as good a sail as on maui. I guess the only thing maui has on us is quantity.
Gerroa on sunday looks good if your keen
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅