If U learn in ideal conditions does it translate?

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
sboardcrazy
sboardcrazy
NSW
8333 posts
NSW, 8333 posts
21 Jan 2011 3:26pm
I've asked this a few times in other topics but no one ever notices so..Ok so you go away to a Guy Cribb clinic or similar in perfect condtions somewhere & crack that carve gybe or chop hop..Does the skill translate to our crappy gusty only occasional windy conditions over here or do you lose it after being home for while when you can't practise regularly.
hardie
hardie
WA
4133 posts
WA, 4133 posts
21 Jan 2011 12:43pm
Yes, because you learn the muscle memory and skill combinations get recorded in your neural circuitry, whule it will be more difficult in non-ideal conditions, you've been hardwired. The hardwiring is much more difficult to develop in less than ideal conditions and particularly if you do it by trial and error rather than learning correctly at first,
sboardcrazy
sboardcrazy
NSW
8333 posts
NSW, 8333 posts
21 Jan 2011 4:00pm
hardie said...

Yes, because you learn the muscle memory and skill combinations get recorded in your neural circuitry, whule it will be more difficult in non-ideal conditions, you've been hardwired. The hardwiring is much more difficult to develop in less than ideal conditions and particularly if you do it by trial and error rather than learning correctly at first,


Grr.. So true..
hardie
hardie
WA
4133 posts
WA, 4133 posts
21 Jan 2011 1:21pm
sboardcrazy said...

hardie said...

Yes, because you learn the muscle memory and skill combinations get recorded in your neural circuitry, whule it will be more difficult in non-ideal conditions, you've been hardwired. The hardwiring is much more difficult to develop in less than ideal conditions and particularly if you do it by trial and error rather than learning correctly at first,


Grr.. So true..


Unfortunately yes, its how human memory and learning works, feels almost impossible for an old dog like me to learn the tricks of freestyle windsurfing even tho I'm very competent, but I've got 26 years of learning memory and neural circuitry to retrain
Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
21 Jan 2011 4:51pm
Its probably like a lot of learning. If you learn a skill in ideal conditions then you find it easier to learn and to become a master of, unless you learn incorrect technique that works in ideal conditions but doesn't in the real world.

An analogy would be learning to drive. You would not want to teach someone how to drive in an old crappy car that has a bad clutch and gearbox on Parramatta Road at 5.30pm Friday arvo. They could learn but it would not be a pleasant experience.

Same as learning to gybe in a strong outgoing current besides a breakwall with wave crashing in. You could learn but it would be hard and probably lethal.

However if you learn somewhere great and learn the correct way to do it then yes it will help you improve. The other thing is you go somewhere like that and all you do for a week or two is windsurf. So you probably get as many hours on the water as what you could get in a year in NSW.



FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15100 posts
WA, 15100 posts
21 Jan 2011 2:38pm
sboardcrazy said...

I've asked this a few times in other topics but no one ever notices so..Ok so you go away to a Guy Cribb clinic or similar in perfect condtions somewhere & crack that carve gybe or chop hop..Does the skill translate to our crappy gusty only occasional windy conditions over here or do you lose it after being home for while when you can't practise regularly.


Yeah? No one notices?

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Windsurfing/General/Gybing-clinic-for-Lake-Macquarie/?SearchTerms=safety+bay

Hmmm... maybe 'someone' doesn't notice

So, yes, again, it does translate to our conditions in NSW as you learn the technique and once that is down pat, it is easier here. You only have to modify your technique slightly to handle different conditions once you have learnt the core of a move.

In a recent trip to Safety Bay it was a bit choppier than usual and a different wind direction. It was a welcome change as it made me have to think about gybing and weighting the rail enough to stop it from bouncing.

mineral1
mineral1
WA
4564 posts
WA, 4564 posts
21 Jan 2011 2:48pm
sboardcrazy said...

I've asked this a few times in other topics but no one ever notices so..Ok so you go away to a Guy Cribb clinic or similar in perfect condtions somewhere & crack that carve gybe or chop hop..Does the skill translate to our crappy gusty only occasional windy conditions over here or do you lose it after being home for while when you can't practise regularly.


If Cribby was any place close, then I would be first in line, cost regardless. Gybe is the one thing, I just cant crack I got that frustrated, I nearly gave it all away a year or so back. In then end I came to the conclusion its one of those things that just isnt easy to do.
sboardcrazy
sboardcrazy
NSW
8333 posts
NSW, 8333 posts
21 Jan 2011 5:56pm
FormulaNova said...

sboardcrazy said...

I've asked this a few times in other topics but no one ever notices so..Ok so you go away to a Guy Cribb clinic or similar in perfect condtions somewhere & crack that carve gybe or chop hop..Does the skill translate to our crappy gusty only occasional windy conditions over here or do you lose it after being home for while when you can't practise regularly.


Yeah? No one notices?

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Windsurfing/General/Gybing-clinic-for-Lake-Macquarie/?SearchTerms=safety+bay

Hmmm... maybe 'someone' doesn't notice

So, yes, again, it does translate to our conditions in NSW as you learn the technique and once that is down pat, it is easier here. You only have to modify your technique slightly to handle different conditions once you have learnt the core of a move.

In a recent trip to Safety Bay it was a bit choppier than usual and a different wind direction. It was a welcome change as it made me have to think about gybing and weighting the rail enough to stop it from bouncing.




I'm old enough to blame senility...
FormulaNova
FormulaNova
WA
15100 posts
WA, 15100 posts
21 Jan 2011 3:18pm
mineral1 said...

sboardcrazy said...

I've asked this a few times in other topics but no one ever notices so..Ok so you go away to a Guy Cribb clinic or similar in perfect condtions somewhere & crack that carve gybe or chop hop..Does the skill translate to our crappy gusty only occasional windy conditions over here or do you lose it after being home for while when you can't practise regularly.


If Cribby was any place close, then I would be first in line, cost regardless. Gybe is the one thing, I just cant crack I got that frustrated, I nearly gave it all away a year or so back. In then end I came to the conclusion its one of those things that just isnt easy to do.


I think Simon Bornhoft was holding clinics in Safety Bay in late 2009. Did anyone go?

Peter Hart was talking about coming over at some stage, but I guess the travel times really discourage them, and I think it would be harder for these guys to get a full clinic.

I wanted to go on a Peter Hart clinic in Dahab a few years back but some idiots decided to let off a bomb there and the clinic was canceled. It was a pity though, as it would be good to see how much better these level instructors are than any others that aren't as well known.

I think the closest they get to us is Mauritius.

Trousers
Trousers
SA
565 posts
SA, 565 posts
21 Jan 2011 6:28pm
so lets say you go to a clinic and the coach watches you and tells you that every time, you go into a gybe, you pull back - trying to counter the anticipated weight of the sail, but really just bogging the tail and stalling the turn. he now wants you step into the gybe, leaning forward so that your hips are well over the centreline. try again for me he says.

so you do. as you come back in and initiate the gybe he's yelling at you "hips inboard!". but you don't quite get there, but over the next few gybes, you're watched and encouraged to commit to the turn and suddenly you do it! it's kind of accidental and all happens so fast that you bollocks up the rig flip, but hey, the carve felt sweet, and inexplicably just 'right'. you now know the feeling you're going for, and even something about how to achieve it. the rest is practice.

sure the conditions when you come back might be different but the principles are now in your mind, and you proved you can do it.

you have "leveled up". congrats, you're now a better windsurfer!
pierrec45
pierrec45
NSW
2005 posts
NSW, 2005 posts
22 Jan 2011 8:39am
Absolute yes to the original question.

I teach both beginners and basic freestyle. I find good conditions remove so many variables, allowing the brain to focus on the trick at hand. Once you get it in ideal conditions or start to, then you get better and better at introspecting on adjustments when you come back home.

Of course none of this applies to moves you still can't perform in ideal conditions - the case with many of mine
sboardcrazy
sboardcrazy
NSW
8333 posts
NSW, 8333 posts
22 Jan 2011 4:39pm
Trousers said...

so lets say you go to a clinic and the coach watches you and tells you that every time, you go into a gybe, you pull back - trying to counter the anticipated weight of the sail, but really just bogging the tail and stalling the turn. he now wants you step into the gybe, leaning forward so that your hips are well over the centreline. try again for me he says.

so you do. as you come back in and initiate the gybe he's yelling at you "hips inboard!". but you don't quite get there, but over the next few gybes, you're watched and encouraged to commit to the turn and suddenly you do it! it's kind of accidental and all happens so fast that you bollocks up the rig flip, but hey, the carve felt sweet, and inexplicably just 'right'. you now know the feeling you'regoing for, and even something about how to achieve it. the rest is practice.

sure the conditions when you come back might be different but the principles are now in your mind, and you proved you can do it.

you have "leveled up". congrats, you're now a better windsurfer!


Thats how I felt after the last windy session.. I finally knew how it felt to keep forward & low.. problem is I don't really know how to replicate it..[}:)]
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅