Rubby said...
Mark, you are only close to the truth. New beginner boards have only improved over the old 12 to 14 footers by becoming fun for anyone trying to teach someone the sport on top of being an intro to modern wide gear. The old boards were actually just as easy to learn on as the new and much more fun in light winds for the novice, especially if you are learning on your own (and isn't this a sport that encourages individualism?). It's the sport that is hard to learn, mainly because it takes dedication and drive, not because of the equipment. It isn't the nature of the equipment that discourages people (unless they aren't using recommended stuff), it's the challenges of windsurfing.
Yeah yeah. I learnt on an old 'one-design' type of board and it was pretty hard to get the balance right, just to stand upright on the board. It took a while but I got there, and found my balance was pretty good. I could happily sail along, tack and sail the other direction. I managed some gybes too.
I managed to find someone who had a newer wide style beginners board and I went from having an okay time to having a great time. I think the use of a modern mono-film sail made a huge difference too.
In my opinion, you would only bother learning on a one design if you had to and otherwise you are better starting on something that is wide and floaty.
For lightwinds I can stick a bigger fin in a beginner board and cruise around. If the winds are slightly stronger I can plane around.
Since I learnt I have occasionally found people that are stuck in a time warp and are using older gear. If they want to know, a quick bit of advice on tuning their gear properly, or using more user friendly equipment can make a dramatic improvement to their sailing fun.