Advice on best carbon boom to buy please

4 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
PedroE
PedroE
2 posts
2 posts
29 Dec 2021 5:52pm
Hi all,
Time to splash out on a carbon boom for my bigger sails - up to 7.7m - so needing one which extends to 210 or 215cm or so.
Any suggestions for reasonably priced and well built models will be appreciated.
Cheers,
Peter
8 posts
29 Dec 2021 6:14pm
www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Windsurfing/Review/Severne-Enigma-Boom-or-Duotone-Platinum-Boom

'Best value' is entirely personal preference. +1 for Enigma from personal experience, a 'bargain' (for their quality), but many will have a different set of price/value/quality/usage criteria and a different perspective.
John340
John340
QLD
3410 posts
QLD, 3410 posts
29 Dec 2021 9:40pm
A number of brands get their carbon booms from the same factory, eg the Duotone EPX Series, Naish. They are solid and good value.
onefoot
onefoot
21 posts
21 posts
29 Dec 2021 9:20pm
X-booms! They come in Slim or regular Diameter, Ultralight or regular, Foil, Slalom or Race. Reasonable priced for their quality.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
29 Dec 2021 9:55pm
^^^ Got me curious so I had a look
No Prices on the site? Looks like great quality no doubt....but would cost a LOT outside of europe surely?

Dunno about cork grip durability rigging on roadway, gravel etc. Any advice here?
ADinis
ADinis
62 posts
62 posts
30 Dec 2021 6:48am
One year ago, I had the same doubts, then i searched a lot and a lot. guess what??

aeron is the "mother" of almost all booms, a lot of sails brands and accessories don't have and dont need to have their own molds to produce their booms, harness lines, extensors and other things. what they do? They ask to "secound ones", it's normal! The only change the grip.

the booms like aeron, old simmer, RRD, gunsails, goya, unifiber (not all), duotone EPX, prolimit, they all are made on aeron and others that i dont know.

i think but i'm not sure, new simmer, loftsails, avanti, they are made in another factory, but i dont know.

of course i bought the gunsails carbon boom, i have the 180-240 and the 230-290 what can i say?? I do like, but i only tried alumunion booms. this gunsails booms are the only 100% carbon booms that i have, i cannt compare with others.



































































Grantmac
Grantmac
2383 posts
2383 posts
30 Dec 2021 7:08am
Things to look for:

Extension marked as total length.
Tail piece holes molded vs. drilled (Simmer X10 has this).
Common hardware (Aeron is very available and quality).
Boom arm shape.
Arm diameter vs. rigidity.
redrabbitz
redrabbitz
VIC
65 posts
VIC, 65 posts
30 Dec 2021 10:08am
Bought a Severne ENIGMA Carbon
Boom 160-210 back in June.

Pricey - Yes.

Quality - Yes.

Performance & Durability - YES.(So far)

Have alloy Naish boom, older Chinook & Hydrodynamics all good units relevant to your interests & needs.


If you're a hardcore sailor go for it Carbon, don't skimp on the mast at least minimum 70%c.

Aeron, Naish, Severne, Unifiber, Goya, Duotone, N.P, etc...all very good. How much you're prepared to depart with $'s & what you wish to gain in durability, longevity & performance. At the end of the day THEY all can be damaged or broken subject to conditions & situations.

duzzi
duzzi
1126 posts
1126 posts
30 Dec 2021 7:37am
PedroE said..
Hi all,
Time to splash out on a carbon boom for my bigger sails - up to 7.7m - so needing one which extends to 210 or 215cm or so.
Any suggestions for reasonably priced and well built models will be appreciated.
Cheers,
Peter


Point-7 makes great booms. I have a 140-190 and cannot be happier. The head feels much moresolid than my severnebooms. It might be because it uses three bolts instead of two.
BSN101
BSN101
WA
2390 posts
WA, 2390 posts
30 Dec 2021 9:06am
NP with inter outhaul system is working well for me. On my larger sails where adj outhaul is desired.
kuotadriver
kuotadriver
61 posts
61 posts
30 Dec 2021 11:49am
That boom end cleat on the Enigma appears to be an improvement on the earlier stainless steel version- mine always seems to work loose
PedroE
PedroE
2 posts
2 posts
31 Dec 2021 5:09pm
Thanks for all the suggestions. In the end I ended up purchasing a Chinook carbon pro slalom boom. Many brands weren't quite long enough or weren't in stock. The Chinook boom looks to be quite well made. It wasn't cheap but hopefully sees me out!
Manuel7
Manuel7
1349 posts
1349 posts
1 Jan 2022 7:47am
Disclaimer: I have a cold, grumpy mode can accidentally be triggered!

I tried most of them and they all have their pros and cons. Streamlined has the stiffest head and feel the stiffest overall but corrodes and disintegrates. The front is also oversized and the head scary to hit!

Neilpryde head was stiff too but now loosens quickly. Aerons is aevrage, same with Chinook. Severne seems one touch above. Duotone source of trouble according to rental centers.

I was super happy with my big gaastra boom back in the day but snapped a super light alloy wave boom.

Sorry to be a downer, I have a cold! I guess if one seldom uses theirs then any one will work!

I'm on simmers now, they do the job but don't feel that stiff despite a tight tail.

PS: I meant to try the Maui sails head, supposed to be a bit stiffer?
mob dog
mob dog
NSW
290 posts
NSW, 290 posts
1 Jan 2022 11:03pm
PedroE said..
Thanks for all the suggestions. In the end I ended up purchasing a Chinook carbon pro slalom boom. Many brands weren't quite long enough or weren't in stock. The Chinook boom looks to be quite well made. It wasn't cheap but hopefully sees me out!


Good choice I say. I have several other chinook bits and pieces and all of them continue to exceed my expectations for quality and functionality. The carbon pro booms look awesome and I would really like one of them too. Let us know what you think of it when you try it out
col5555
col5555
WA
386 posts
WA, 386 posts
2 Jan 2022 7:23am
I have two Al360 booms bought in 2016 and 2017
No structural dramas what so ever.
No elongated holes, no head clamp problems boom grip is still good although a little tatty in places.
I sail quite a lot so they are well used.
I have just ordered replacement levers as the cleats have finally corroded away near to nothing.
They come in a v grip style so easy on hands.
Made in Italy
JakeNN
JakeNN
372 posts
372 posts
10 Jan 2022 5:09am
+1 for AL360 V-Grip.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅