115/105, volume puzzle

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
jmaster
jmaster
4 posts
4 posts
4 Jan 2012 7:49pm
Hello, I sailed my 115/66cm width Rocket for a while now, but I am considering to trade it in for a 105 Rocket. (63cm width) I want to use this board for mainly 6.5 weather, 15-20 knots, and I have this idea that a 105 board is better suited for a 6.5 sail.

Would the 105 be an improvement or is it not worth the hassle? I weigh 80 kilos and sail mostly inland, most common winds here are 14-18 knots.... My 2nd board down will be an 86 FSW board. Would love to hear other opinions!
Mobydisc
Mobydisc
NSW
9029 posts
NSW, 9029 posts
4 Jan 2012 11:02pm
Hi,

I have a 105 Rocket. I have only used it with my Loft 02 5.9m sail. To be honest I'm a bit scared to use my 6.6m Loft 02 with it. However that is me. My other board is a Rocket 140 and it's a bit big or the 6.6m sail.

Based on what others have said the 105 would would work well with a 6.5m sail. Go for it. I will soon.

I weigh around the same as you.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
4 Jan 2012 10:01pm
It is only one step down in size, so a fin change could probably achieve almost the same effect.

If you get the 105, then you have lost the lighter wind option so maybe just get a smaller fin for the 115?

Just thoughts......
wespyyl
wespyyl
WA
118 posts
WA, 118 posts
5 Jan 2012 10:08am
3cm width isn't going to do a huge amount I wouldn't think.

Just keep it and get a 7.5 for light days.

And take the FSW out when it's over 22-23 knots.
Ian K
Ian K
WA
4169 posts
WA, 4169 posts
5 Jan 2012 12:05pm
I've got the 115 rocket. It's pretty versatile. Goes really well fully powered up with a 5.7 and the standard 38cm fin. Also about 80 kg. I sometimes think a 105 would be nice but you can have too many boards with too much overlap.

Can't see why you'd go for a smaller fin. A small fin on a wide board doesn't make sense (unless you move the footstraps in as well) . Maybe it's a myth perpetuated by fin manufacturers?
sideskirt
sideskirt
328 posts
328 posts
5 Jan 2012 3:54pm
Imo don't change it....

I have 85kg, traded 113L (66cm wide) Fa Eagle for 105 Thommen (62,5 cm wide), eventhough it's a great board, it just doesn't suit me in lighter days, lacks a bit to get planing easily.
When I bought an 88L wave board I noticed even more, that I can't use the 105L as I would like to...

End result=selling the 105 and buying a 110L Skate.

ikw777
ikw777
QLD
2995 posts
QLD, 2995 posts
5 Jan 2012 7:08pm
I'm 78kg and have the following:

115 / 68cm wide(7.5m -6.5m)
104 /63 cm wide (6.5m - 5.8m)
86 / 58cm wide (5.2m-4.5m)

I agree that 105 is an excellent board size for use in 6.5 weather - really nice. I have found a noticeable step down in size from 115 to 104 though and it definitely won't get going as well in lighter winds. I'd keep the 115 and add the 105. Everyone needs three boards.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
5 Jan 2012 6:20pm
Ian K said...

I've got the 115 rocket. It's pretty versatile. Goes really well fully powered up with a 5.7 and the standard 38cm fin. Also about 80 kg. I sometimes think a 105 would be nice but you can have too many boards with too much overlap.

Can't see why you'd go for a smaller fin. A small fin on a wide board doesn't make sense (unless you move the footstraps in as well) . Maybe it's a myth perpetuated by fin manufacturers?


Cos when well powered at top end of the range for that board it will have too much lift and rail up.
Every board needs two fins IMHO.
Waveboards have too small a fin for pro's in well powered conditions and I suspect some freeride stuff is a bit large so they can claim early planing and upwind ability, but downside is some are a handful in 20kn+

If the O.P finds his board a tiny bit too big (implied by only wanting 10L less?) the same effect can be achieved with a $100 fin not a $1000 changeover cost on a board, yet retaining the lighter wind option is an advantage.
But like I said it was just thoughts, everyone wants different things
jmaster
jmaster
4 posts
4 posts
5 Jan 2012 6:47pm
Hey Guys and thanx SO much for all your thoughts, really helps me. Very interesting to read how you think about/handle these things.

In the end I want a 3 board quiver. I weigh 78-80 kilo, so I was thinking a 75-77 liter waveboard (in a couple of years?), a 86 liter FSW (soon) for my 5.6 and 4.7 sails and then above that a 105-115 lighter wind board for blasting with my 6.5 and 5.6. (still have to buy a 7.5)

Yes, a board change would be a fxcking big hassle, and I already bought a MFC Liquid Pro fin 32 fin, which I though I could use mith my 5.6 sail. Though it might be a weird size when I think about it. Too big for a 5.6, and too small for my 6.5 sail.... I didn't use it, yet. (I have a 5.6 and 6.5 sail) The wind here in the Netherlands is mostly between 14-18 knots. I bought and sold a couple of boards already since I am always doubting what is best for me. For example, I bought a 125 Rocket which at the time was too small for me because I sucked at windsurfing then. 20+ Sessions later, I improved so much that I sold the 125 and bought a 115. Exactly for that reason: wind here is mainly lighter wind. For hardcore days I am considering a RRD FSW 86...

Does this info make a difference on what I should do? I am afraid I might regret another change down, just like sideskirt though I weigh 7-8 kilo's less. It's just that the 6,5 sail is the sail I use the most by far, and then a 105 might be a better fit? ****, it probably is just all in my head!!!
ikw777
ikw777
QLD
2995 posts
QLD, 2995 posts
5 Jan 2012 9:19pm
If the wind really is mostly 14 to 18 knots then the 105 and a 6.5 should be great. Use a big fin for the low end and your 32 for the high end. I use a 37 and a 34 most with my 104 and only sometimes the 29 it came with). You'll Probably find you'd be wishing for your 115 at 14 kts though.

If you want to move to a three board setup then it seems to me you've already got two of them. Just add the 105.
Ian K
Ian K
WA
4169 posts
WA, 4169 posts
5 Jan 2012 7:26pm
Mark _australia said...


Cos when well powered at top end of the range for that board it will have too much lift and rail up.
Every board needs two fins IMHO.



Probably some truth in that, you hear it so many times. But I'm thinking a good percentage of it is the placebo effect, people get a bit sketchy overpowered, believe a small fin is going to solve all the problems, change down, go out again with more confidence, and bingo it happens.

I can't see why the standard fin suddenly develops too much lift? More speed? More angle of attack? You're not going that much faster?

Without any good explanation to the contrary I'm of the belief that the standard sized fin keeps the board balanced and better able to soak up the chop. Believe that and you can get by with one fin per board.

If you must use a smaller fin get a smaller board to go with it. A 95 litre ~ 58 cm wide one.





ikw777
ikw777
QLD
2995 posts
QLD, 2995 posts
5 Jan 2012 9:57pm
Ian K said...

Mark _australia said...


Cos when well powered at top end of the range for that board it will have too much lift and rail up.
Every board needs two fins IMHO.



Probably some truth in that, you hear it so many times. But I'm thinking a good percentage of it is the placebo effect, people get a bit sketchy overpowered, believe a small fin is going to solve all the problems, change down, go out again with more confidence, and bingo it happens.

I can't see why the standard fin suddenly develops too much lift? More speed? More angle of attack? You're not going that much faster?

Without any good explanation to the contrary I'm of the belief that the standard sized fin keeps the board balanced and better able to soak up the chop. Believe that and you can get by with one fin per board.

If you must use a smaller fin get a smaller board to go with it. A 95 litre ~ 58 cm wide one.



More force from the sail exerting sideways pressure on the fin. Nothing to do with speed...?

Ian K
Ian K
WA
4169 posts
WA, 4169 posts
5 Jan 2012 8:06pm
Well the sail can only exert the pressure that you can counter balance. Smaller sails may exert a little more force if they have the centre of effort less distance from the mast foot , that way you have more leverage over the sail and hence can hold a bit more sail force. But I don't think it's that much, the larger sails seem to have proportionally more shape down below and that may cancel the effect out. So I'd say for a given rider, sails pretty well develop the same force fully powered up regardless of size.
ikw777
ikw777
QLD
2995 posts
QLD, 2995 posts
5 Jan 2012 10:16pm
But you can't counteract the sideways force. The sail, board and you are going to be pushed sideways. More so the windier it gets. Some of this is converted into forwards motion by the fin, but as the wind builds the sideways force becomes greater and therefore the lateral pressure on the fin too, hence the tail starts to rise.

Oh, I could be wrong though...
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
5 Jan 2012 9:19pm
Ian K said...

Mark _australia said...


Cos when well powered at top end of the range for that board it will have too much lift and rail up.
Every board needs two fins IMHO.



Probably some truth in that, you hear it so many times. But I'm thinking a good percentage of it is the placebo effect, people get a bit sketchy overpowered, believe a small fin is going to solve all the problems, change down, go out again with more confidence, and bingo it happens.

I can't see why the standard fin suddenly develops too much lift? More speed? More angle of attack? You're not going that much faster?

Without any good explanation to the contrary I'm of the belief that the standard sized fin keeps the board balanced and better able to soak up the chop. Believe that and you can get by with one fin per board.

If you must use a smaller fin get a smaller board to go with it. A 95 litre ~ 58 cm wide one.





Using a board in the middle of it's intended wind range only, then yes you are right. However we don't do that, else we all need 3 boards. I disagree greatly on the placebo effect though, seriously if you use whatever board you have at the top end of it's range with standard fin, then change down a size it will be sooo much easier. Likewise at bottom end in barely planing territory.

Don't we have a variety of sail sizes? Using your logic we should all still have 2 sails and put up with them outside their intended range

All I am saying is that is he is regularly using his largest board in conditions that make him think about dropping 10L (not much of a drop). In that case he can save a lot of coin by using a smaller fin - we are talking a board used 2-3kn above its intended wind range here, 10L is not much difference, one fin size kinda difference. Then he still has the volume for the days that are not so windy.

And yes, too large a fin does cause railing up caused by too much lift - ridiculously so when on the limit
Ian K
Ian K
WA
4169 posts
WA, 4169 posts
5 Jan 2012 9:37pm
No the logic of one fin doesn't apply to sails. The speed of the wind you expect to flow over the sail varies widely from day to day, so you pick an appropriately sized sail. The speed of water you might expect to flow over the fin doesn't vary to the same degree.
jmaster
jmaster
4 posts
4 posts
5 Jan 2012 9:54pm
What is "railing up"?

The reason for this change down board/or fin idea was that once I was going really fast with my 115/6.5 and at pretty hard windgusts my board felt like it wanted to fly and I hard a hard time keeping it "on the ground". At other times that session when the wind dropped it sometimes was actually hard to (get into) plane.... Personally, when I read all these tips and so on, I feel like a smaller fin would indeed help... Though perhaps my 32 fin is too small for my 6.5 sail?
sboardcrazy
sboardcrazy
NSW
8333 posts
NSW, 8333 posts
6 Jan 2012 9:52am
I weigh about 63kgs.
I have a 125 Rocket I sail in 5 - 20kts if its gusty and there are obvious lulls. It comes with a 44cm freeride fin which I use until it gets c 18kts + when I use a 30cms one and that really settles it down. This is with a 6.6m sail ( I don't have any bigger worse luck).
I have a 95 rocket I use in 18 (consistent) - 25kts with a 30cms freeride in lighter winds ( 5.8m - 5m) & 26cms ( 4.2m) B & J in close to 25kts. It really helps the board 'stick ' to the water better and not threaten to throw me off.So I find changing to a smaller fin does work. I do tend to use a larger board for my weight than most people here recommend but we don't get the nice consistent wind of WA and I like to be on a board that will keep going/ be less of a pain through the lulls.
BIGKYM
BIGKYM
SA
127 posts
SA, 127 posts
6 Jan 2012 12:31pm
Agree with the smaller fin option...i use a 115 Rocket up to 25knts with a 6,4m sail and 38cm fin as soon
as the board starts to rail up or feels like only the tip of the fin is in the water..i change fin to a 34cm
and it makes the board sit back down on the water..but it doesn't make it go any faster!!
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅