Broken boom

7 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
MorningBird
MorningBird
NSW
2707 posts
NSW, 2707 posts
2 Jan 2019 4:44pm
I spent a few hours on MB installing a overflow bottle for the coolant and greasing the sheet winches. A good day except I lost my glasses overboard in 6 metres. It had to happen eventually.
As I was rowing out I saw a new boat. Looks like a harbour boat, nothing onboard to suggest it is a passage maker. Sturdy things these vessels.
What is the consensus on the cause?

Toph
Toph
WA
1880 posts
WA, 1880 posts
2 Jan 2019 2:01pm
Quadrant Marine has the solution according to their website..

A badly rigged preventer possibly
chris340
chris340
NSW
43 posts
NSW, 43 posts
2 Jan 2019 5:12pm
Perhaps hoisting the topping lift, rather than the halyard?
Gravy7
Gravy7
NSW
242 posts
NSW, 242 posts
2 Jan 2019 5:30pm
The length of the boom from the mast to the break looks about the same as the distance to the side stays.

So I would say it's most likely from an uncontrolled gybe.

Not a great advert for Quadrant Marine!
Subsonic
Subsonic
WA
3413 posts
WA, 3413 posts
2 Jan 2019 2:56pm
Hard to tell from one picture.

It could well have just broken under vang load (ie not up to task). it looks like it probably snapped upwards from the way the alloy has beer canned horizontally at the bottom, maybe it hit a stay as Gravy said, then in its weakened state, snapped.

There's plenty of ways it might have happened though.
nosecabin
nosecabin
2 posts
2 posts
3 Jan 2019 1:27pm

due to shaking a reefed main out with the topping lift and vang, still attached.
it snapped at the vang attachment point.

i learned the hard way.
fishmonkey
fishmonkey
NSW
494 posts
NSW, 494 posts
3 Jan 2019 5:08pm
must of been cranked pretty tight!
Yara
Yara
NSW
1317 posts
NSW, 1317 posts
3 Jan 2019 6:15pm
Looks like the boom was either made from two pieces, or repaired, with a a stiffener added below the joint. If the vang is strut type, then sheet load could have broken it.
Crusoe
Crusoe
QLD
1197 posts
QLD, 1197 posts
3 Jan 2019 7:14pm



Jolene
Jolene
WA
1624 posts
WA, 1624 posts
3 Jan 2019 5:30pm
nosecabin said..

due to shaking a reefed main out with the topping lift and vang, still attached.
it snapped at the vang attachment point.

i learned the hard way.



Thats a bummer, looks repairable though.
A nice sporty looking carbon fiber splint would be just the shot
stray
stray
SA
325 posts
SA, 325 posts
3 Jan 2019 8:31pm
Its a pretty flimsy looking boom to start with, and look where the mainsheet attaches.
the aft half of the boom is unsupported, so it could have snapped trying to get leach tension with the rather powerful looking vang.
Yara
Yara
NSW
1317 posts
NSW, 1317 posts
3 Jan 2019 9:55pm
stray said..
Its a pretty flimsy looking boom to start with, and look where the mainsheet attaches.
the aft half of the boom is unsupported, so it could have snapped trying to get leach tension with the rather powerful looking vang.


Yes, that mainsheet attachment system is strange, and your theory is logical. However the bulge at the bottom of the fracture point should have made it strong in tension. The clean break also points to a botched weld repair. This boat is a 2003 US production design so you would expect it to be well sorted.
Trek
Trek
NSW
1208 posts
NSW, 1208 posts
5 Jan 2019 5:47pm
I bought a new boom for my Martzcraft 35 2 years ago, it's nearly double the diameter of that one. Sailmalker estimated size to suit sails. So does look very light weight to me.
Chris 249
Chris 249
NSW
3570 posts
NSW, 3570 posts
5 Jan 2019 6:12pm
Is it really called "Upyers"? What a tacky name -a bit like calling a boat "F%#k You".

If someone is going to sail around on a boat that is abusing everyone else then it's hard to feel sympathy when they break something.
w8ingforwind
w8ingforwind
QLD
259 posts
QLD, 259 posts
5 Jan 2019 7:20pm
Proventer or stay the kink in the boom suggests a horazontal load.
Trek
Trek
NSW
1208 posts
NSW, 1208 posts
6 Jan 2019 8:08am
Chris 249 said..
Is it really called "Upyers"? What a tacky name -a bit like calling a boat "F%#k You".

If someone is going to sail around on a boat that is abusing everyone else then it's hard to feel sympathy when they break something.


His last boat must have been a power boat, they stick with the off names
shaggybaxter
shaggybaxter
QLD
2664 posts
QLD, 2664 posts
6 Jan 2019 8:25am
Well, a gybe could do it, it does look a bit flimsy.
Pot calling kettle....





Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅