I don't trust Seabreeze anymore

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Loftywinds
Loftywinds
QLD
2060 posts
QLD, 2060 posts
15 Jul 2014 8:02am
I just don't trust the forecasts, especially FNQ.
Maybe it's because we're in Winter? Gustier? Less predictable?
I mean, when have the forecasts ever been spot on for more than a day?!
Looking at Cairns and compared to BOM, Sbrz is way over excited!
evila
evila
VIC
66 posts
VIC, 66 posts
15 Jul 2014 9:19am
If it's any consolation it hasn't been much better in South East Queensland either. We were meant to have a 20+ day on Sunday but all we got was about 12knots just before dusk... VERY disappointing...

They are forecasting another good day this weekend, so I'm hoping they can get 1 in 2 right at least.
Gilly3
Gilly3
QLD
800 posts
QLD, 800 posts
15 Jul 2014 10:09am
evila said..
If it's any consolation it hasn't been much better in South East Queensland either. We were meant to have a 20+ day on Sunday but all we got was about 12knots just before dusk... VERY disappointing...

They are forecasting another good day this weekend, so I'm hoping they can get 1 in 2 right at least.



Got up to 25 knts on the Goldy last Sunday........

Awesome day in the surf.............YeeeeooOoow

Forecast was spot on
glendog
glendog
QLD
520 posts
QLD, 520 posts
15 Jul 2014 12:12pm
You must have been standing behind a wall or something evila. It was howling all day. The only reason i came in after 3 hours was frostbite.
kiter101
kiter101
QLD
115 posts
QLD, 115 posts
15 Jul 2014 6:41pm
Loftywinds said..
I just don't trust the forecasts, especially FNQ.
Maybe it's because we're in Winter? Gustier? Less predictable?
I mean, when have the forecasts ever been spot on for more than a day?!
Looking at Cairns and compared to BOM, Sbrz is way over excited!


i think your the one over excited
Dl33ta
Dl33ta
TAS
463 posts
TAS, 463 posts
15 Jul 2014 7:48pm
evila said..
If it's any consolation it hasn't been much better in South East Queensland either. We were meant to have a 20+ day on Sunday but all we got was about 12knots just before dusk... VERY disappointing...

They are forecasting another good day this weekend, so I'm hoping they can get 1 in 2 right at least.


Depends on how you're reading the forecast. The seabreeze arrows and the BoM marine text forecast are averages for that particular wind zone which usually covers hundreds of miles north/south and at least 10 miles east/west. So in the case of SEQ on Sunday it was blowing well over 20kts offshore but 10-20 inshore, take the average of that and its right on the money. The probability of an averaged forecast ever being right for the point you are standing is remote unless the wind strength is uniform across the whole sector.

If you want to know what the wind is going to be doing inshore for your area start looking at either the 8 day NOAA model (GFS) which I think Seabreeze uses or the BoM 3 day model (ACCESSR) which I think is pretty good. People have their favourite models but I've found the BoM one to be spookily accurate 24hrs out from 0 to 50 miles offshore all up and down the QLD coast.
Loftywinds
Loftywinds
QLD
2060 posts
QLD, 2060 posts
16 Jul 2014 8:35am
Dl33ta said..
evila said..
If it's any consolation it hasn't been much better in South East Queensland either. We were meant to have a 20+ day on Sunday but all we got was about 12knots just before dusk... VERY disappointing...

They are forecasting another good day this weekend, so I'm hoping they can get 1 in 2 right at least.


Depends on how you're reading the forecast. The seabreeze arrows and the BoM marine text forecast are averages for that particular wind zone which usually covers hundreds of miles north/south and at least 10 miles east/west. So in the case of SEQ on Sunday it was blowing well over 20kts offshore but 10-20 inshore, take the average of that and its right on the money. The probability of an averaged forecast ever being right for the point you are standing is remote unless the wind strength is uniform across the whole sector.

If you want to know what the wind is going to be doing inshore for your area start looking at either the 8 day NOAA model (GFS) which I think Seabreeze uses or the BoM 3 day model (ACCESSR) which I think is pretty good. People have their favourite models but I've found the BoM one to be spookily accurate 24hrs out from 0 to 50 miles offshore all up and down the QLD coast.


Ahh. It's how you use the hammer that counts! Thanks heaps for those tips. Cheers
glendog
glendog
QLD
520 posts
QLD, 520 posts
20 Jul 2014 5:01pm
they definetly stuffed it up this weekend.
Hardcarve1
Hardcarve1
QLD
550 posts
QLD, 550 posts
20 Jul 2014 7:15pm
I treat kiting as a seasonal past time in SE Queensland pack the gear away in April and bring it back out in September. Sure there are days you can go out but anything west is just not much fun. Now if a low moves down the coast which they used too then that's another story.
Caney
Caney
SA
118 posts
SA, 118 posts
22 Jul 2014 8:42pm
Bull **** Glen,

I kited all day Sunday. Was perfect, 6 hour session!
glendog
glendog
QLD
520 posts
QLD, 520 posts
23 Jul 2014 7:26am
Haha mate if i wanted to drive around the broad water like what you do id get in my boat. It doesnt count if you never leave the water.
Jared888
Jared888
WA
389 posts
WA, 389 posts
23 Jul 2014 8:19am
It wasn't that long ago that we had to go check the coast and look at synoptic s,
looking back I really enjoyed it actually,
Thanks Sea breeze for the heads up on conditions,
But I don't think its fair to hold a forecast for ransom,
If forecasts/predictions could be I'd be at local palm reader asking for the lotto results
Loftywinds
Loftywinds
QLD
2060 posts
QLD, 2060 posts
23 Jul 2014 3:02pm
Jared888 said..
It wasn't that long ago that we had to go check the coast and look at synoptic s,
looking back I really enjoyed it actually,
Thanks Sea breeze for the heads up on conditions,
But I don't think its fair to hold a forecast for ransom,
If forecasts/predictions could be I'd be at local palm reader asking for the lotto results



Yeah but they are so far off course, I might as well hinge by chances on solar winds around the moon!

Look at Earthnull school.net. Now that's accurate.
Jared888
Jared888
WA
389 posts
WA, 389 posts
23 Jul 2014 1:07pm
Loftywinds said..

Jared888 said..
It wasn't that long ago that we had to go check the coast and look at synoptic s,
looking back I really enjoyed it actually,
Thanks Sea breeze for the heads up on conditions,
But I don't think its fair to hold a forecast for ransom,
If forecasts/predictions could be I'd be at local palm reader asking for the lotto results




Yeah but they are so far off course, I might as well hinge by chances on solar winds around the moon!

Look at Earthnull school.net. Now that's accurate.


Not at home right now but a couple of weeks ago I started to use the Elders weather around the SW,
yep sea breeze I agree was well off the mark here to, Elders was alot better tha SB that week, which puzzled me be cause I thought they used the same weather stations
Loftywinds
Loftywinds
QLD
2060 posts
QLD, 2060 posts
29 Jul 2014 6:00pm
Could this be the start of the season for us Marv?




kemp90
kemp90
QLD
1694 posts
QLD, 1694 posts
30 Jul 2014 1:57pm
Loftywinds said...
Could this be the start of the season for us Marv?







Fingers crossed
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅