Four kite surfers were lucky to survive

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Mini Mal
Mini Mal
WA
298 posts
WA, 298 posts
1 Nov 2011 7:43am
From Herald Sun
FOUR kite surfers were lucky to survive after their jet ski broke down in Port Phillip Bay.

The men were kite surfing about 7.5km from Sorrento when the jet ski they were relying on to tow them to shore faltered on Saturday.

The alarm was raised when one of the men phoned for help.

Water police and the Southern Peninsula Rescue and Coastguard pulled the four from the water after dark.

The first man, stranded on the jet ski, was rescued at about 10pm.

Police on jet skis eventually reached the other kite surfers, who were stuck on Mud Island, at about 1am.

"The conditions that night were horrendous," Leading Senior Constable Jay McDonald.

"It was dark and stormy with squalls of up to 40 knots and rain.

"The jet skier was adrift in the middle of a busy shipping channel and if he hadn't had his iPhone on him he would not have been able to raise the alarm."

What really went on out there?
Joe Cron
Joe Cron
NSW
450 posts
NSW, 450 posts
1 Nov 2011 11:44am
What's the problem? There was 40 knots of wind.
Saffer
Saffer
VIC
4501 posts
VIC, 4501 posts
1 Nov 2011 1:03pm
Guys, if you're gonna kite on in the one place you're not allowed to and that the tree huggers are going to have a field day with, at least make sure your jet ski doesn't break down. What do you think is going to happen when these guys (http://home.vicnet.net.au/~fomi/) get hold of them and how much bad publicity is kitesurfing going to get as a result.
Andrash
Andrash
WA
637 posts
WA, 637 posts
1 Nov 2011 10:35am
something is really wrong with that article.
How can all 4 presumably experienced kiters get in trouble off-shore in 40kn or so wind?
How can one single jet ski tow 4 kiters to shore, and why needs to if there is wind?

Weren't they 4 surfers by any means? At least it would sound a little more realistic.
deanrobi
deanrobi
VIC
641 posts
VIC, 641 posts
1 Nov 2011 1:58pm
The Jet Ski was used to ferry the kiters out to Mud Island, which is in the middle of the bay and is supposedly a great flat water spot. The winds that night were WSW which would have meant that the kiters would have needed to kite up wind to get back to land, no easy feat
Joe Cron
Joe Cron
NSW
450 posts
NSW, 450 posts
1 Nov 2011 2:41pm
deanrobi said...

The Jet Ski was used to ferry the kiters out to Mud Island, which is in the middle of the bay and is supposedly a great flat water spot. The winds that night were WSW which would have meant that the kiters would have needed to kite up wind to get back to land, no easy feat


A kiter unskilled enough to get upwind in 40kn isn't experienced enough to be attempting a spot like this.
NickT
NickT
WA
1094 posts
WA, 1094 posts
1 Nov 2011 11:42am
In 40kts I can go upwind real easy!

what was forecast wind wise and what gear did they have?
chronic
chronic
NSW
318 posts
NSW, 318 posts
1 Nov 2011 2:50pm
Joe Cron said...

What's the problem? There was 40 knots of wind.


hahaha...

can someone chuck a map up
hamburglar
hamburglar
ACT
2174 posts
ACT, 2174 posts
1 Nov 2011 2:56pm


A kiter unskilled enough to get upwind in 40kn isn't experienced enough to be attempting a spot like this.


+1 on this one

a couple of hours on an island in port phillip bay, What the?
its a wonder they didn't start eating each other being away
from civilisation for so long,hope they weren't starting to be
attracted to each other ,you know everyone has needs
wishy
wishy
WA
1501 posts
WA, 1501 posts
1 Nov 2011 12:29pm


I can't go downwind in 40 knots! you go too fast!
NickT
NickT
WA
1094 posts
WA, 1094 posts
1 Nov 2011 2:11pm
^^^ what do you mean dude, ive seen you go heaps fast downwind on your stopmach in 40 kts
deanrobi
deanrobi
VIC
641 posts
VIC, 641 posts
1 Nov 2011 5:20pm

I'm guessing that they would have been on bigger kites during the afternoon as we were kiting on 12m at Rosebud late that afternoon before the SW change came thru

10+ Km upwind on bigger Sz kites in 30-40 Knots at dusk/night sounds like a hoot, i can't imagine why they didn't kite home
kitingtopher
kitingtopher
SA
313 posts
SA, 313 posts
1 Nov 2011 5:04pm
why didn,t they kite back before dark? more to this story than is being told. good thing the jet ski had a phone . Why would you need to tow kite surfers.?
kitingtopher
kitingtopher
SA
313 posts
selwyn
selwyn
VIC
23 posts
VIC, 23 posts
1 Nov 2011 6:03pm
I was the guy on the jet ski.

I'll never go out there again. The currents are too strong and the island is hard to access on a boat- perfect for a jet ski but the waves come up too much when the wind hits 25kts in the channel.

We had a boat going out to pick the guys up at 7pm but the driver panicked saying it's too shallow so we had to come back and use the jet ski. By then it was 8pm...almost dark.

It's scary when the tide is running out to Bass Strait, plus whats more the cops are telling me it's a shark breeding ground...nice.

I'll stay in St Kilda on the next southerly.
selwyn
selwyn
VIC
23 posts
VIC, 23 posts
1 Nov 2011 6:06pm
You can't kite back, it's off shore- when you get close to the beach the water is deep and the high land and cliffs cause turbulence.
surfingboye
surfingboye
NSW
2707 posts
NSW, 2707 posts
1 Nov 2011 6:11pm
Good job, lucky to be alive.
ewan kite
ewan kite
VIC
928 posts
VIC, 928 posts
1 Nov 2011 6:45pm
selwyn said...

I was the guy on the jet ski.

I'll never go out there again. The currents are too strong and the island is hard to access on a boat- perfect for a jet ski but the waves come up too much when the wind hits 25kts in the channel.

We had a boat going out to pick the guys up at 7pm but the driver panicked saying it's too shallow so we had to come back and use the jet ski. By then it was 8pm...almost dark.

It's scary when the tide is running out to Bass Strait, plus whats more the cops are telling me it's a shark breeding ground...nice.

I'll stay in St Kilda on the next southerly.


ye, its really not the place to be, super strong currents and if something goes wrong its not the place you want to be, a large shark breeding ground. Ill also never be going again, not worth the risk
deanrobi
deanrobi
VIC
641 posts
VIC, 641 posts
1 Nov 2011 7:48pm
Good to see you guys are safe Selwyn, That has definitely quelled any planned trips that I may have had to visit that place, I will stick to carpark 14.



kiteboy dave
kiteboy dave
QLD
6525 posts
QLD, 6525 posts
1 Nov 2011 7:17pm

"The jet skier was adrift in the middle of a busy shipping channel and if he hadn't had his iPhone on him he would not have been able to raise the alarm."


Paid product placement, thanks journo.
GalahOnTheBay
GalahOnTheBay
NSW
4188 posts
NSW, 4188 posts
1 Nov 2011 9:02pm
selwyn said...

I'll never go out there again. The currents are too strong and the island is hard to access on a boat- perfect for a jet ski but the waves come up too much when the wind hits 25kts in the channel.

We had a boat going out to pick the guys up at 7pm but the driver panicked saying it's too shallow so we had to come back and use the jet ski. By then it was 8pm...almost dark.

It's scary when the tide is running out to Bass Strait, plus whats more the cops are telling me it's a shark breeding ground...nice.

I'll stay in St Kilda on the next southerly.


Sounds like it has all the ingredients for a great "secret spot"

Good to hear everyone got back ok.

PS: By secret spot I mean somewhere that is epic once every 3 years, and otherwise something about the conditions makes it a complete waste of effort.

dafunk
dafunk
QLD
561 posts
QLD, 561 posts
1 Nov 2011 8:43pm
glad it ended ok
**** happens hey?
wdric
wdric
NSW
1625 posts
NSW, 1625 posts
1 Nov 2011 10:56pm
Although the jetski still needed to be rescued, Unless I am missing something, if they were all experienced and it was in the middle of the bay and there was heaps of wind and it was SW, I guess they could have just kited to the other side of the bay in less than 1hr? looks to be 20 or 30 km?

Land the kites and phone a friend

Probly would have been on terra firma before dark and home earlier than waiting for rescue

StinkyPete
StinkyPete
WA
241 posts
WA, 241 posts
1 Nov 2011 8:05pm
surfingboye said...

Good job, lucky to be alive.


your avatar is turning me on
djdojo
djdojo
VIC
1614 posts
VIC, 1614 posts
2 Nov 2011 12:21am
GalahOnTheBay said...
Sounds like it has all the ingredients for a great "secret spot"

Good to hear everyone got back ok.

PS: By secret spot I mean somewhere that is epic once every 3 years, and otherwise something about the conditions makes it a complete waste of effort.



It's also a relatively secret spot to a bunch of species other than homo sapiens and the more secret it stays on that front the better. Sure there's some adventure appeal but really we've got plenty of other good kiting spots that aren't habitat to a bunch of critters who I'm sure would be a bit freaked out by invasions of giant dacron birds.
dirtyharry
dirtyharry
WA
444 posts
WA, 444 posts
1 Nov 2011 10:03pm
djdojo said...

GalahOnTheBay said...
Sounds like it has all the ingredients for a great "secret spot"

Good to hear everyone got back ok.

PS: By secret spot I mean somewhere that is epic once every 3 years, and otherwise something about the conditions makes it a complete waste of effort.



It's also a relatively secret spot to a bunch of species other than homo sapiens


No need to call people homos. Expected more from a smart fella like you dojo.
Andrash
Andrash
WA
637 posts
WA, 637 posts
1 Nov 2011 10:09pm
After reading all as it unfolds, and not familiar with the spot itself, it sounds to me as follows:
4 kiddies let go of daddy's hand, and went for an adventure without much consideration... and cried for daddy, when it all gone a bit shaky...
Long gone the time when men took the consequences of their actions, and later sat around a (symbolical) fire and laughed and laughed remembering how they got out of the sh!t they created for themselves on the way of growing up....
BoDiddly
BoDiddly
VIC
622 posts
VIC, 622 posts
2 Nov 2011 12:50pm
Went out one day on our boat 'Sea Coffin' to Mud Island went for a swim lovely day...
Then got back a mate spoke to the dude doing heli tours, said that we were nuts swimming there as he regularly sees sharks circling the island.... Sheet!
windsufering
windsufering
VIC
1124 posts
VIC, 1124 posts
2 Nov 2011 1:18pm
Kiters a real smart will become a hero for being soooooooooooooooo stupid










hitch_hiker
hitch_hiker
WA
492 posts
WA, 492 posts
2 Nov 2011 10:22am
windsufering said...

Kiters a real smart will become a hero for being soooooooooooooooo stupid


Hey? A bit early to be drunk!

harry potter
harry potter
VIC
2777 posts
VIC, 2777 posts
2 Nov 2011 2:19pm
hitch_hiker said...

windsufering said...

Kiters a real smart will become a hero for being soooooooooooooooo stupid


Hey? A bit early to be drunk!




Its never too early in WA !!
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅