Poll !

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
southace
southace
SA
4795 posts
SA, 4795 posts
1 Dec 2013 10:42pm
Have not seen a poll for a bit!

After all that has been said, who believes there should be a cull of the GWS a simple yes or no?

SandS
SandS
VIC
5904 posts
VIC, 5904 posts
1 Dec 2013 11:25pm
Yes get rid of all interstate AFL teams and go back to VFL
southace
southace
SA
4795 posts
SA, 4795 posts
1 Dec 2013 11:11pm
I know what your trying to say its to cold for water sports in Vic but thanks for your input!
sn
sn
WA
2775 posts
sn sn
WA, 2775 posts
1 Dec 2013 8:43pm
sounds good to me- then we can go back to "state of origin" matches and watch you VFL fellas cringe

never really have liked the over the top AFL, much prefered "local" footy.
even suburban games with real amateurs [wot work propa jobs to pay the bills] are better than spoilt AFL princesses

stephen
[flame suit on]
southace
southace
SA
4795 posts
SA, 4795 posts
1 Dec 2013 11:14pm
It's always the way trolls ruin polls!
WA71
WA71
WA
1382 posts
WA, 1382 posts
1 Dec 2013 9:16pm
I don't know. If there is one how would they do it?

I like the tag and siren idea
Craig66
Craig66
NSW
2466 posts
NSW, 2466 posts
2 Dec 2013 12:21am
Yes, if a human eater
southace
southace
SA
4795 posts
SA, 4795 posts
2 Dec 2013 12:42am
Craig66 said..

Yes, if a human eater


It's really hard to single them out mate ......don't be difficult yes or no please!
pweedas
pweedas
WA
4642 posts
WA, 4642 posts
1 Dec 2013 10:39pm
Yes, if they are in the area of an attack.

The trouble with yes and no answers is that they can then be used to justify an action which is easily shown to be inappropriate.
PaddlePig
PaddlePig
WA
421 posts
WA, 421 posts
1 Dec 2013 10:43pm
Yes. Hunt them like any other fish. Size limit and bag limit. Fill the fish and chip shops
Toph
Toph
WA
1880 posts
WA, 1880 posts
1 Dec 2013 11:11pm
If it must be a black and white answer, then I'm

Yes

pweedas
pweedas
WA
4642 posts
WA, 4642 posts
1 Dec 2013 11:33pm
WA71 said..
I don't know. If there is one how would they do it?

I like the tag and siren idea


So is that a yes or a no?
One bark for no, two barks for yes.
And why have you left your doggie unattended in the dog pound?
Sailhack
Sailhack
VIC
5000 posts
VIC, 5000 posts
2 Dec 2013 11:22am
Definitly No to culling...

but a big Yes for the combination of PaddlePig's idea (which I posted the same on another thread) and the author's tag/siren system.

Make it legal to fish for GWs again with bag/size limits. As most fishos won't keep them but want to catch them for the 'sport' - make it compulsory that if a GW is caught, it has to be tagged with a device that works on southace's system. Pretty soon, most rogue sharks close to land will have electronic tags and send off sirens...the downside to this is that we'll know when nearly 'every' GW shark is in proximity of our beaches...the siren might go off more than you think guys!
Toph
Toph
WA
1880 posts
WA, 1880 posts
2 Dec 2013 10:39am
True true Sailhack.

I'm not 100% pro cull, but if you want a straight up yes or no answer then I fall onto the yes side of the fence. I haven't always held that opinion though.
jbshack
jbshack
WA
6913 posts
WA, 6913 posts
2 Dec 2013 11:00am
It think it would be good to get a poll for Seabreeze? Laurie and chance


Mackerel
Mackerel
WA
313 posts
WA, 313 posts
2 Dec 2013 11:13am
Yes
Sailhack
Sailhack
VIC
5000 posts
VIC, 5000 posts
2 Dec 2013 2:32pm
Just in addition to my comments - I live in Vic, which is very low in shark attacks and possibly has bearing on my decision not to cull. I sympathise for those who have lost friends and didn't want to come across as insensitive. Although GWs do migrate - I can appreciate those living in 'hotspots' wanting to cull and wouldn't be adverse to culling if it was in those specific areas in order to make the beaches safe.

I know it sounds hypocritical as I'm against culling in general - but I doubt the GW population would be largely affected by 'targeted' culls in some areas. My only concern is that as soon as culling gets the green light - it opens up to making it happen along the entire coastline - which wouldn't be ok by me.
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
2 Dec 2013 2:39pm
The moment the sharks leave the water and start attacking the people ON THE BEACH shoot them then........without hesitation.
If they are still in the water (their domain) leave them alone.... Yes tag and track for research but NOT kill.
Boothie88
Boothie88
161 posts
161 posts
2 Dec 2013 12:12pm
Nes Yo.
Ian K
Ian K
WA
4169 posts
WA, 4169 posts
2 Dec 2013 12:17pm
From what I can gather.

1. The GWS move about a lot
2. There's no evidence that any single shark has developed a taste for humans and become a repeat offender

Therefore attacks are due to chance encounters.

To reduce the incidence of chance encounter by 50% you either reduce the number of swimmers by 50% or the global shark population by 50%

There's 3,500 GWS according to Wikipeadi, conservation status is vulnerable.

Cull 1,750 vulnerable GWS to reduce the toll by 50%

No

If you can't handle the current low probability of getting bitten don't go in the water.
Gizmo
Gizmo
SA
2865 posts
SA, 2865 posts
2 Dec 2013 3:13pm
WA71
WA71
WA
1382 posts
WA, 1382 posts
2 Dec 2013 12:46pm
Ian K said..

From what I can gather.

1. The GWS move about a lot
2. There's no evidence that any single shark has developed a taste for humans and become a repeat offender

Therefore attacks are due to chance encounters.

To reduce the incidence of chance encounter by 50% you either reduce the number of swimmers by 50% or the global shark population by 50%

There's 3,500 GWS according to Wikipeadi, conservation status is vulnerable.

Cull 1,750 vulnerable GWS to reduce the toll by 50%

No

If you can't handle the current low probability of getting bitten don't go in the water.


Spot on. Further to the point, surfers, kitesurfers and windsurfers + divers etc should be the only ones whos opinion counts (water users in general, not land lubbers or sailors)
GypsyDrifter
GypsyDrifter
WA
2371 posts
WA, 2371 posts
2 Dec 2013 2:05pm
WA71 said..

I don't know. If there is one how would they do it?

I like the tag and siren idea


+1
WA71
WA71
WA
1382 posts
WA, 1382 posts
2 Dec 2013 2:25pm
GypsyDrifter said..

WA71 said..

I don't know. If there is one how would they do it?

I like the tag and siren idea


+1


sebol
sebol
WA
753 posts
WA, 753 posts
2 Dec 2013 2:34pm
no
MintoxGT
MintoxGT
WA
975 posts
WA, 975 posts
2 Dec 2013 2:35pm
No
mineral1
mineral1
WA
4564 posts
WA, 4564 posts
2 Dec 2013 3:41pm
Yes
MintoxGT
MintoxGT
WA
975 posts
WA, 975 posts
2 Dec 2013 9:49pm
I just had the sh1t scared outta me, I walked into the kitchen and there it was........... the TOASTERrrrrrrrrrrrrrr!
MintoxGT
MintoxGT
WA
975 posts
WA, 975 posts
2 Dec 2013 9:51pm
mineral1 said..

Yes


Why would you say yes? You only sail in water deep enough to snap your ankle ;)

Just kidding mate.

Hope yr well.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅